Showing posts with label World Cup. Show all posts
Showing posts with label World Cup. Show all posts

Thursday, July 9, 2026

Soccer in the United States - A Fan's Perspective (Post 2026 World Cup Exit)

What's wrong with the USMNT.

I say that not with a question mark but with a period because I know. I know what's wrong with the USMNT.

The problem is...

You know what? Before I tell you what's wrong, let's back up a little.

As I'm writing this, it's been just a few days since the United States Men's National Team exited the stage that is the FIFA World Cup with a 4-1 defeat to Belgium in the Round of 16 in Seattle. I would say that it's because I didn't want to write my immediate emotions, but I was atypically calm about the entire game. I do like to do some research though and the past few days have provided that chance. 

The USMNT won their group stage after just their second game, winning both of their first two group stage games against Paraguay (a 4-1 victory in Los Angeles) and Australia (a 2-nil victory in Seattle) before losing to Turkiye (a 3-2 loss back in L.A.) while resting most of their starters. The US then played Bosnia and Herzogovina, getting a 2-nil victory in the San Francisco Bay Area Stadium. 

In that game against Bosnia and Herzogovina, USMNT player Folarin Balogun was issued a red card based on a VAR review of a moment between Balogun and Muharemović which determined that Balogun's inadvertent stepping on Muharemović's ankle was a reckless challenge. The USMNT played the final 26' + 11' of stoppage time down a man, but extended their lead from 1-nil before Balogun's ejection to 2-nil on a magical free kick by Tillman from just outside the penalty area. 

In the ensuing days, people discussed whether it was or wasn't a red card, could the USMNT appeal the card or not, and generally is VAR helping or hindering the sport these days. There seemed to be a general consensus from the broadcast personnel and their "Soccer Rules Analysts" that VAR likely broke protocol by showing Brazilian official Raphael Claus the still images of the exchange between Balogun and Muharemović before showing the full speed exchange. So Belgium and USMNT players prepared for their game without Balogun. Until Sunday, when it was announced that his red card would be suspended for the game with a 1-year probation period to follow. Rumors and reports followed consisting of the President of the United States making a call to FIFA President Infantino to look into the red card. Suddenly, and surprisingly, the USMNT's top scorer was back in play.

Belgium then went out and bossed the USMNT all over the field, getting their first goal just 9 minutes into the first half. The USMNT would claw one back in the 31st minute, again from a Tillman free kick, only to concede minutes later to go back down. Mauricio Pochettino had tried to change the momentum by making a substitution at halftime, but to only moderate and temporary success. Belgium would add a third goal in the second half on a spectacular mistake from USMNT GK Freese, and would then tack on a fourth in stoppage time from second half substitute Lukaku just for good measure, emphatically putting an exclamation point on the domination of the game. Christian Pulisic left the game minutes after Belgium's third goal with a leg injury (now reported as a bone bruise and microfracture).

Which is where we find ourselves today. Talking about a USMNT that, once again, made it to the Round of 16 but no further. 

So what's wrong with the USMNT?

If you've listened to the talking heads (including many former players) and the internet, everything. I've heard:

  • Pulisic didn't step up. As "Captain America," people expected more from him. He needed to play injured.
  • Pochettino didn't select or play the right players and/or didn't make the right tactical decisions, including his decision to not play the starters in the third group stage game.
  • Balogun's red card was a distraction.
  • The President of the United States messed with the soccer gods and karma struck back immediately.
  • This "golden generation" of soccer players for the USMNT just don't have the fight, the mentality to compete against the top teams in the world.
  • The US wasn't sufficiently tested in the lead-up to the World Cup because they were automatic qualifiers.
  • The United States' youth development program is a shambles and worthless.
  • The United States doesn't have its best athletes playing soccer, they're playing other sports like football, basketball, baseball...
  • We call it soccer instead of football.
  • We don't have promotion/relegation in the country.
  • Etcetera, etcetera, etcetera.
The answer to what's wrong with the USMNT. It's really easy. 

NOBODY REALLY F**KING KNOWS!

Why would I know the answer? I'm just a guy who writes about his local club for the past baker's dozen years, but has played the game, refereed the game, coached the game (albeit to little kids), watched the game, and discussed the game for nearly the entirety of my life. So I do have some thoughts.

Maybe it's a little bit of all those things in that list. Maybe not, and in some cases, probably or definitely not. It takes some legit mental gymnastics to buy into the "best athletes are playing other sports" thing when arguably one of the greatest to ever play the game is 5'-7" and 150 lbs. Messi doesn't fit the "best athletes" physique those folks have in mind, but there's no denying his ability, skill, and instinct around the goal. The karma thing could be real though. As we like to say in America for other sports, "ball don't lie." Getting politicians involved messed with the karma. I have sports superstitions so I can buy into that one.

Maybe it's as simple as the United States played a bad game against a good team at the wrong time and they were beaten. Having lost to Belgium earlier this year, albeit with some slightly different players, lends credit to the fact that maybe the USMNT just didn't match up well against this Belgium team.

Maybe Belgium took the momentum from their late comeback win against Senegal and the anger/frustration about the Balogun reinstatement and used it all as fuel to play the kind of soccer a Top 10 ranked team can play despite having some struggles in the group stage.

Maybe, and I'm just spit balling here, maybe it's really difficult to win in world soccer. 

Maybe, just maybe, the top teams in the world are the top teams in the world for a reason. Maybe they've just been able to pull all the right strings together to get the right resources with the right players at the right time with the right culture to consistently win games. Maybe that's not easy to duplicate even with some number of any of those factors aligning for other countries.

The World Cup has been played 22 times before this iteration. Eight (8) countries have won it. Eight. 
  • Brazil (5 - 1958, 1962, 1970, 1994, 2002)
  • Germany (4 - 1954, 1974, 1990, 2014)
  • Italy (4 - 1934, 1938, 1982, 2006)
  • Argentina (3 - 1978, 1986, 2022)
  • France (2 - 1998, 2018)
  • Uruguay (2 - 1930, 1950)
  • England (1 - 1966)
  • Spain (1 - 2010)
  • And only 5 other countries have ever made the final game (Netherlands runners-up 3 times, Hungary 2 times, Czechoslovakia 2 times, and Sweden and Croatia 1 time each)

Let's look at this another way. Looking at the official FIFA rankings from June 11th, right before the start of the World Cup, 30 of the top 34 teams in the world made it into the expanded field of 48, with only Italy (ranked 12th), Denmark (21st), Nigeria (26th), and Ukraine (32nd) not making it into the tournament. There were 6 additional teams inside the top 50 of the rankings, with the final 12 teams consisting of teams at a ranking of 50 or higher (Uzbekistan at 50 up to New Zealand at 85). For refence, the United States came into the tournament ranked at 17th.

Digressing slightly, Italy is a four-time winner and didn't even make it into the field. Since they won in 2006, they've exited the tournament twice in the group stage, and haven't qualified the past 3 tournaments. Germany is also a four-time winner and after winning it in 2014 didn't make it out of the group stage in 2018 or 2022 and lost in the Round of 32 this year. And US fans were upset about missing the 2018 tournament...

Back to my larger point, in the Round of 32, there were four teams that were ranked in the Top 32 that didn't advance: Uruguay (16th), Iran (20th), Turkiye (22nd), and South Korea (25th). So those four plus the four that didn't even make the tournament, otherwise 24 of the 32 positions were filled by countries that were ranked in those positions pre-tournament. The other 8 positions in the Round of 32 were rounded out by teams ranging from the Ivory Coast (33rd) to Ghana (73rd). 

Favorites vs Underdogs Results
The Round of 16 was filled by 10 teams that were ranked in the Top 16. The United States (17th), Switzerland (19th), Egypt (29th), Canada (30th), Norway (31st), and Paraguay (41st) made it into the Round of 16 from outside the Top 16 rankings. 

Of the Round of 32 games, only Paraguay's win over Germany (9th) was from a team with a lower ranking. From the Round of 16 games, only Norway's (31st) win over Brazil (6th) and Switzerland's (19th) win over Columbia (13th) were games with wins by the lower ranked team. 15 of the 16 Round of 32 games were won by the higher ranked team, and 6 of the 8 Round of 16 games were won by the higher ranked team. The above image was created before the France/Morocco game, but that one also was won by the higher ranked team, France.

As we like to say here in Indiana during the NCAA March Madness tournament, this World Cup is "going chalk." The higher seeded teams are generally winning when they need to win. Sure, there have been some amazing games. Argentina has been pushed to the brink twice by significant "underdogs." England v Mexico is probably still my favorite game of the tournament so far. But the higher seed has prevailed most of the time.

The United States (17th) played to chalk too. They beat a Paraguay (41st) team 24 spots behind them. Chalk. 

They beat an Australian (27th) team ten spots behind them. Chalk. 

They lost to a Turkiye (22nd) team five spots behind them in the rankings after conceding a 90'+8' goal. So they nearly got a draw from that game with a highly rotated squad. Almost Chalk. 

They beat Bosnia and Herzegovina (64th) despite being a man down for a significant portion of the second half and stoppage time. Chalk. 

The lost to Belgium (9th). Chalk.

Like most USMNT fans, I was disappointed and frustrated at the loss on Monday night to Belgium. "It's the hope that kills you," right? I let myself get excited for the "why not US" propaganda that FOX has been feeding us because of how well the US was playing in the early games of the group stage and that they overcame the struggle of the red card to still advance. Like most soccer fans in this country, I wanted to see them get over the Round of 16 hump, but it just didn't happen. However, I didn't feel like the sky was falling Monday night and I still don't think the sky is falling today. I think the USMNT got outplayed by a better team, which has been a theme for much of this tournament. Cape Verde gave Argentina as much as they could handle, and Egypt did the same until Argentina's class finally kicked in in the 79th minute, but with only a couple of exceptions, the world class teams have come through each time in this World Cup.

So where does that put us as it relates to the USMNT?

Last year, I wrote an article about my local club, Indy Eleven, where I discussed Expectations versus Reality. With very little effort, what I wrote about Indy Eleven can apply to the USMNT, so I'll reiterate it here with the appropriate edits:

I have had versions of this conversation over the years with various people, but the following quote has been the most eloquent way I have heard to say it: "Conflict arises when expectations exceed reality."

There's an expectation that Indy the USMNT is one of the top clubs teams in the league world. As a result, there is an expectation that Indy the USMNT should be consistently at the top of the standings and winning most of their games. When that doesn't happen, people want to blame the coaches or the players or any number of reasons for them not meeting the expectation. The reality is that Indy (not counting the USL W league team or the Academy teams)  the USMNT has only had a modicum of success, spread out over just a few seasons in the twelve-year history of the team tournaments. Indy The USMNT have a history of expectations exceeding reality. While this year's team is underperforming based on last year's results, t The reality is that they're right where history has told us this team will be: 

With the exception of the 2018 World Cup that the US didn't qualify to play in, the team has only not made it out of the group stage once since their quarterfinal run in 2002 (exited in the group stage in 2006), and have been a consistent fixture in the Round of 16 (4 out of 4 times they've been in the tournament). The expectation was that they should be progressing further than their predecessors because they're the "golden generation," the best the United States has ever fielded. The reality is that while this team improved, they're not the only ones. It's not a stagnant finish line that they're chasing. The other countries in the world have a say in this too.

So where does the USMNT go from here? Tuesday was officially Day 1 of the next World Cup cycle. 

Will Pochettino be around? His contract with the USMNT has expired but the US Soccer Federation has offered him an extension through the 2030 World Cup. Whether he takes it or moves on is still to be determined.  

What players from this team continue to be part of it? The average age of the team was 26-years old so there are clearly some players who will be age eligible to continue their time on the team. At 38 years old now, Tim Ream is, likely, not one of those players, but nobody thought he would be there this time. Cristian Roldan will be 35 years old so maybe he's not in the mix either. Matt Turner will be 36, but goalkeepers age differently in this sport so he might be a possibility, but he wasn't even the starter for this World Cup. After that though, every other single player on this roster will be in their late 20s or early 30s. 

I can hear some of you now, get rid of all of them. Why would we keep trying to use players that can't get it done? "Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." Because until some players step up and displace them, they were determined by Pochettino to be the best (or healthiest at the selection time) available. As I argued in my earlier Expectations vs Reality article for Indy Eleven, the USMNT have talented players. Saying they don't is foolish and you're basing your opinion on the last result, which for 47 of the 48 teams in this tournament will not be as World Cup winners. When healthy, Pulisic is still a dynamic player. In the first two games, Weston McKennie was the engine that drove the team. Tyler Adams covers a lot of mistakes that others make. Freeman, Tillman, Balogun. All of those players deserve to make a case for themselves, and I think they will all continue to be part of the team for the foreseeable future. Whether that extends to 2030 will be dependent on who steps in, steps up, and takes their positions from them.

I don't think he was fully healthy, but I think there's going to be a place on the team for a guy like Diego Luna. He's fearless, which can be enough to unsettle opposing defenders. Much like Emma Hayes has done for the USWNT, the early stages of this new World Cup cycle should be met with bringing in a lot of players from wherever they can find them. At one point last year, Hayes had given 32 players their first cap. The old guard is starting to give way to the new guard, and I know there are players around the country (or playing in other countries) that deserve the chance. I just assume that the men's team's old guard aren't quite ready to concede their positions yet. 

Though given the vitriol I've seen towards some of them lately, I don't know why they would want to continue to put themselves through this shit. It's a lot of fans' prerogative, but if you're an American wanting them to fail, then you and I are on different wavelengths on what we think is good for the sport. 

Which gets me to my final point.

Go support soccer. Call it soccer if you want. Call it football if you want. Find a team, preferably local because there are plenty of them at all levels of the US Soccer pyramid, and go to games. Watch games on television or the internet. Find a foreign club if that works for you (I support Motherwell in the Scottish Premiership).

Some of you may have found soccer for the first time in any real way with this World Cup. Welcome. Welcome to the madness. Try to not let some of the gatekeepers hold you back. If you have questions about the game, there's somebody, not a gatekeeper, who is more than willing to share their knowledge with you about the game. To talk about the game. To laugh and cry about the game. 

I've explained it a few times on this site over the years about how I arrived at the name of my site, the Game Beckons, but I'll summarize it again here.

I had reread Finding the Game: Three Years, Twenty-five Countries, and the Search for Pickup Soccer, by Gwendolyn Oxenham and watched the companion documentary Pelada, when I was thinking about names for my site. I remembered a quote from Luke when they were in Marseille, France, when Gwendolyn writes the exchange in the book (the same exchange occurs in the film):

"Five or six games stretch across the park. We stand there watching, weighing, still wondering whether or not the jersey once belonged to Drogba. A ball skips towards us. Luke takes off after it and volleys it back. He's quiet for a second. Then he says, "When the ball comes toward me, I consider the game beckoning me - the game wants me."

There's another point in the book where Gwendolyn writes about an exchange while they were in Italy talking to a writer, Cristiano, who reads from his own book and then helps them understand his meaning (emphasis mine):

"He pours us grappa and translates the meaning, hands gesturing, "It is a story about an old man who imagines what he'll say to his grandson...that there is a god for the soccer fields, a kind of magic. Not the big ones - the small ones in the provinces." Head cocked to the side, he smiles, shyly like he's telling us something personal, emotional: "Soccer will give you much more than you can give it."

Soccer in the United States is going to be fine. It might not be the meteoric rise that some would like of it, but the USMNT will get better. I believe they will eventually make it beyond the Round of 16 again. They might also not qualify again. Germany and Italy have proven how hard qualifying and performing in the World Cup can be. 

I, personally, believe that the USMNT will get better. But I plan to be here either way.   

If the World Cup beckoned to you, enjoy it. As somebody who has continued to have the game beckon to me for the past 50 years, I agree with Luke and Cristiano. The game will beckon you and it will give you more than you give it. That I can promise you is true.

Friday, July 10, 2015

Women's World Cup - NYC Parade

I took some screen captures of the USWNT ticker tape parade thinking that some of them wouldn't look as good as I had hoped. Some did end up being a tad fuzzy after I converted them as best I know how to do, but I'm still going to include them here.  This was a cool thing for the USWNT to be able to experience less than a week after winning the World Cup.  You might notice that I had a favorite group. I also thought that I had captured everybody during the parade portion, but I don't see Abby Wambach in them. Though I did get her during the presentation portion of the activities.






























Tuesday, July 7, 2015

Women's World Cup Final - U.S. vs Japan


There's so much that can be said about this game, but it all comes down to the above photo. The United States found their offense, found it early, found it in bunches, and rode that wave to its first World Cup Championship since the famous 1999 victory against China. A generation of women who watched that 1999 game aspired to do the same thing and finally found the promise land.

Remember when the United States men scored a goal in 30 seconds in last year's World Cup against Ghana, scoring so quickly it seemed to take them out of their game plan?  From my experience, the USWNT does not have that problem.  If you score early, that just means that you have a lot more time to score again.  If you score in the 3rd minute, then you can score again in the 5th minute. If you do that, you might as well score in the 14th minute.  While you're at it, score again in the 16th minute just to make sure that everybody remembers that the United States knows how to score. Then let the defense that has carried the load to the Final do their part too.  While a couple of rare defensive mistakes lead to two Japan goals, this game was never really in question before it reached its quarter mark.

Carli Lloyd drives me crazy, but when she's feeling it, she's one of the most dangerous midfielders in the world. The run that she did for the first goal was a thing of beauty. She ran from 35 yards out on a beeline through the penalty spot towards the 6-yard line to get the ball.


The second was putting herself in a position for a rebound, which she did.

The hat trick goal?  Are you kidding me?  To even attempt that shot, that's somebody who is bristling with confidence.


I said it on Twitter, but lost in the Lloyd hat trick was a spectacular goal by Lauren Holiday. A goal that FIFA agreed was one of the Top 10 in the tournament. I've seen comments about it not being a good goal, but it's not nearly as easy as she made it look. A first-time strike on a ball dropping from 35-feet in the air and hitting it before it ever hits the ground with so much pace that it goes right over the goalie before they have time to react? That's world class even if she made it look simple.





This was a total team win, highlighted by the early onslaught of goals, that finally shed the 1999 monkey on their collective backs.



Photo source, source

Wednesday, July 1, 2015

Women's World Cup - U.S. vs Germany

WWCGraphics
When Carli Lloyd gets on a goal-scoring streak, the goal must seem like it's twice as big for her.  While her 69th minute goal was from the penalty spot, there was no doubt about it.  Even if Angerer had chosen to dive the correct way, there was enough pace on Lloyd's strike that I don't think Angerer would have saved it.  Then she turned around 15 minutes later, made a defender miss, went end-line, and served up a perfectly placed ball at the 6-yard line for second half substitute Kelly O'Hara to effort her way to her first international goal. After the game, O'Hara indicated that she saw the pass go into Lloyd and thought that it might come across the goal face and knew she needed to get there to try and make a play on it. For a player who played every minute of the 2012 Olympics, but has struggled to see playing time recently, she's the poster child of the depth and desire of this American team. Get your chance and make the most of it.

Alexi Lalas has repeatedly said that Julie Johnston is his MVP of the American team during this World Cup tournament, but I disagree.  It seems like every recent tournament has produced a "break-out" player and Johnston certainly fits that description for this tournament. She's a beast and I think the center-back position is in good hands moving forward as Rampone is likely to retire. I also don't think it's Rapinoe nor Lloyd who are the MVP and have seemingly done most of the scoring in this tournament.

Sauerbrunn.

Sauerbrunn is my MVP. It seems to me that Sauerbrunn is the foundation for a defense that has not given up a goal in 513 minutes (and counting). In a game pitting #1 (Germany) vs #2 (U.S.), the top scoring offense (Germany) in the tournament vs the top scoring defense (U.S.) in the tournament, the defense won and won soundly.  The pundits and hacks (I'm looking at you US Today writers) may say that the ref gifted the United States two breaks (more on those in a minute), but the United States was the better team during the game. For me, that all results from a confidence that the defense is going to play well and that starts with Sauerbrunn.  She may not win any MVP awards, but her leadership is the key to that scoreless streak.

Now about the two PKs.

Yes, Johnston pulled down Popp. Yes, it was deserving of a yellow and a penalty kick. I don't think, however, it was deserving of a red because I think refs are discouraged from double-penalizing a team. The yellow and PK penalized Johnston and the U.S., but a red card would have doubled that call by also forcing the team to play a player down. It may not be a popular decision, but I believe it was the correct one to penalize the way it was done.

Morgan's PK was close.  It's the assistant referee's responsibility to help the head referee determine whether the player was in the box or not, especially if the referee is blocked.  By the replays I saw, the foul was close enough to the line that from the two ref's angles, it likely looked like it occurred within the box. You don't like to award a PK if it isn't deserved, but it didn't appear that Morgan flopped and a lot of times that call with go to the offensive player. Missed calls can be debated forever and with the benefits of replays and a dozen camera angles, we forget that there are only four sets of eyes that have the final say.

The USWNT played a great game against a great opponent and deserved to be in the Final. They'll likely be favored against Japan in a rematch of the last World Cup Final, but without the "team of fate" label associated with the Japan team. Should make for an interesting game though.

I'm predicting 2-0 United States.

Monday, June 29, 2015

Women's World Cup - U.S. vs China

WWCGraphics
The United States won this game 1-0 thanks to a Carli Lloyd header in the 51st minute, but this game was really never in question.  The United States dominated from start to finish, thanks in large part to the spark created by the addition of Amy Rodriguez, Kelly O'Hara, and Morgan Brian into the starting lineup as a result of Rapinoe and Holiday having to sit due to yellow card accumulation.

A-Rod had a horrible shank that should have been a goal in the 2nd minute and a few offside calls against her because of her eagerness to push forward and push forward as fast and as hard as possible.  O'Hara was equally disruptive to the Chinese midfield and defense.  Brian had a few rough touches at times (something I've seen others accuse of Holiday), but overall, was very solid in her defensive midfield role, thereby allowing Lloyd to push forward. Heather O'Reilly was freed from the bench and played well too.

In a game that really never felt in doubt, more of a "when" the goal happens and not "if" the goal happens, I'm not going to talk about it much.  Except to say that this was the type of game that the U.S. needed to get some of their mojo back.  They looked impressive at all positions and with much more pace and effort than has been visible during the rest of the tournament.

With that in mind, how do they move forward against Germany?  Nearly everybody has said that Holiday is the team's best #10 and that Rapinoe is one of the most creative on the team. Yet the team looked markedly different with them watching from the stands. Markedly better.  So do you play your best players or the ones who are playing better together?  Or was the lineup against China the perfect one against that team, but won't be as effective against a team like Germany?

Tony DiCicco correctly stated during the broadcast that Carli Lloyd is a streaky goal scorer and is one of the most talented midfielders in the world when she's on a streak. How do you take her out? I don't know how you keep Rapinoe and Holiday out, but does O'Hara, Brian, and Rodriguez's efforts go unrewarded by sitting them back down on the bench?

Personally, I put Holiday back in for Brian and let O'Hara and A-Rod start against Germany.  Let them continue to press the German defense like they did against China. They're basically rested and hungry. By doing so, maybe they can release both Holiday and Lloyd together to not have to drop back so far to help the back four.  Then I rotate Press and Leroux (who is also hungry to play in Canada) in for Morgan or A-Rod and Rapinoe in for Heath.

I've been saying that a lot though. Use the team's depth and speed at the forward position (and no, Wambach is no longer included in that) and run the German defense ragged.  With the spectacular play from the United States' defense, release the midfield and forwards to attack, even against the number 1 in the world (and most offensive) team in the tournament.

Tuesday, June 23, 2015

Women's World Cup - U.S. vs Colombia

WWCGraphics
The sky is falling!

The sky is falling!

The sky is...wait, what?  They won? So why is everybody acting like they lost?

They only scored two goals? With a man advantage for the entirety of the second half?

Maybe it's because it's hard to get into any kind of damn rhythm when you keep getting fouled, but none of them are called and the only calls that were whistled were against the United States.  I'm not a conspiracy theorist, but does anybody else find it amazingly convenient that the only two American players coming into the game with yellow cards have such "horrendous" fouls that they both get booked IN THE FIRST HALF!  By a ref whose native country (France) could potentially see the United States in the semi-final...  I'm just saying.

22 to 12.  That was the fouls called count.  I watched the game and that was not how I saw the game. Just because a player falls, it doesn't mean they were fouled. Even my 7 year old asked why some fouls were called and others were not. Cards for the U.S. that looked exactly like non-calls for Colombia.  I'm just saying...

I'll agree that this is not the prettiest of soccer from the USWNT. I'm not sure why Heath, the right winger, spent so much time in the middle of the field. Colombia clogged the middle with numbers so the flanks were always open. That could have been attacked better. I'm starting to see people's point about set pieces when Wambach is in that they might not normally do with her out, but between her and Julie Johnston, they make a formidable pair in the air.

Cat Whitehill wanted to see a "statement" game out of the U.S. Her "statement" game apparently consisted of a 3-0 win or more. What I think she got was a gritty, grind-it-out and advance statement from the U.S. against a team that had some nice segments and possession, but ultimately never really tested the goal.  Everybody wants to see the U.S. score a lot of goals, but the way the defense and Solo are playing, it may not take a lot to win.

Let's talk about the goal scoring for a minute in this tournament.  The narrative today has been that the U.S. only scored 2 (one from the penalty spot, that could have been two (or more depending on your opinion of the Rapinoe fouls)), while France and Germany scored 3 and 4, respectively.  Guess what other teams scored multiple goals in the Round of 16; England (2).  Four games out of the 15 played had multiple goal scorelines.  So how did everybody look in the group stages? I think you have to throw out Germany's 10 goal effort against Thailand and everybody in Group C's effort against Ecuador as being anomalies. If you do that, high scorer in each group looks like this:
  • Group A was China with 3, 
  • Group B had Germany had an adjusted 7 or 8 and Norway 8 (who also put a 4-spot on Thailand), 
  • Group C had Cameroon with 9 and Switzerland with 11 (10 of which came against Ecuador)
  • Group D had 3 of the 4 teams with 4 goals (and Nigeria with 3)
  • Group E was Brazil and Korea with 4 goals
  • Group F was France with 6, England and Colombia with 4
The high scorers in the group have fared as follows in the Round of 16:
  • China - 1
  • Germany - 4
  • Norway - 1
  • Cameroon - 0
  • Switzerland - 0
  • Australia - 1
  • Sweden - 1
  • Brazil - 0
  • Korea - 0
  • France - 3
  • England - 2
  • Colombia - 0
Goals are hard to get as you progress in the World Cup and the U.S. hasn't allowed a goal since the 27th minute mark in the Australia game (the U.S.'s first game of the tournament).  Colombia had two shots on goal and I wouldn't say that either of those were very threatening.  Two goals by the U.S. was a good result for this stage of the tournament.

Source
I'm not worried yet.  I was nervous during the game considering how how many dives the Colombia team was taking and that it could have resulted in other undeserved cards or a set piece near goal, but I'm not nervous yet for the long-term.  It's going to be interesting to see how the lineup gets changed for the game against China with Rapinoe and Holiday out, but this team's depth has always been a strong suit of this team.  It could be the perfect time to switch the tactics to include another forward and let them attack the China defense with abandon and clear out some of the space in what could be a crowded midfield again.  Though I think I said that before the Columbia game too.

The sky's not falling yet.  That's just the sound of high expectations.

Friday, June 19, 2015

Women's World Cup - U.S. vs Nigeria

Source: WWCGraphics
A 45th minute goal from Wambach is what ultimately gave the U.S. the win, but there were plenty of chances, especially in the first 15 minutes.  However, the USWNT's execution of the set pieces were not up to their normal standard.  For a team that handles set pieces as poorly as the Nigerian team against a team that plays them as well as the United States, there should have been more goals scored. I don't like the short corner attempts from the U.S.  Especially when the lineup includes Wambach, Morgan, and Johnston who are excellent at heading on corner kicks.  They're ok to attempt at times when you see something with the way the opponent is defending the kick, but not when that team is Nigeria.

I reserve the right to change my mind and while I love both of them, Rampone and O'Hara can enjoy the World Cup from the sideline unless one of the starting back four is tired or the game is already won.  Sauerbrunn and Johnston have an amazing connection and are playing spectacular beside each other. The way that Sauerbrunn, Johnston, Klingenberg, and Krieger are playing as a group, you don't change that chemistry.  Even when Rampone came in during the second half, it was for a midfielder and she played left back allowing the Sauerbrunn/Johnston combo to remain.  Rampone has mentored Sauerbrunn well and they look to be doing an equally effective job with Johnston. Julie Foudy has been saying that this team should be playing a 4-3-3 lineup and with the way that the back four and Solo are playing, I can't disagree with her. Let the back four do what they've been doing and attack, attack, attack.  Get the early lead and make the other team chase the game.  Then take advantage of what DiCicco calls "the U.S. trap" where the U.S. continually increases their level of play until the opponents can't keep up with them.

DiCicco and Whitehill were big on two players during the game; Morgan and Holiday.  I can't disagree with either of their assessments.  Morgan looked dangerous all game and she and Wambach have a clear connection that the other combinations of forwards just don't seem to have to the same extent. I think that as long as they are both healthy, and I agree with DiCicco that Wambach looked tired at the end, it gives more weight to Foudy's 4-3-3 lineup.  Pair those two with a third speedster (and take your pick between Press, Rodriquez, or Leroux) and let Holiday/Lloyd/Rapinoe/Health/O'Reilly run the other team's midfield and defense ragged by possessing and constantly serving in balls.

There was this series of comments from DiCicco throughout the game:

  • "But here's something the U.S.A. is doing differently. Lloyd is sitting deeper in the midfield and their best #10 player, Holiday, is higher."
  • "And that's what the U.S.A attack has been missing. That little combination there. Holiday underneath a forward."
  • "I thought that first half was the best half for the U.S.A and I think one of the reasons is Lauren Holiday left the #6 position and became more of a #10 position."

All of those preceded this final exchange between he and Whitehill:
DiCicco: "that was good flowing soccer by the U.S.A. there and Holiday's in the center of it."
Whitehill: "I'm with you Tony on Holiday being higher. She's a special player and one of her special gifts is her final pass and she just creates so much more for the U.S...Holiday, I just love her fluidity in the middle and her and Lloyd are playing much better in this game."
DiCicco: "If you talk to Jill Ellis she will tell you 'our best #10 player is Lauren Holiday.'"

This is where things don't make sense to me. You play your best goalie, you make sure you have good center backs, and you make sure that the right person is playing in the position that connects the defense to the offense.  If that person is Holiday, and according to the coach it is, then that should be where she is played.  The U.S. is flush with talent and if within all that talent is one player that stands out as the best to connect the defense/midfield with the forwards, start there.

The World Cup has a path full of teams that will have more defensive and offensive prowess than Nigeria.  That means the USWNT may need to score more than one goal, which means that you have to get the ball to the forwards.  Winning the group helped create a better path to win it, but you have to put your best players in their best positions.

I hope that the Nigeria game was a step in that direction.

Monday, June 15, 2015

Women's World Cup - USA vs Sweden

Source: WWCGraphics
The United States Women’s team played Sweden to a 0-0 draw in their second game of Group D play, which allows the USWNT to remain on top of the group standings.  The stats reflect a slight edge to the U.S. in the game, but the highlight of the game for either team was the 77th minute goal line save by Meghan Klingenberg.  It’s a good thing she’s 5’-2” because if she had been 5’-1”, I think that ball goes into the goal.

The ball stayed out of the goal and it was one more example of the defensive unit of the USWNT playing superb team defense.  Krieger, Johnston, Sauerbrunn, and Klingenberg did a great job stifling the Swedish attack to the point of the official stats (link to FIFA full stats) showing Sweden getting 9 shots, but none of those were on goal.  Sweden’s defense was equally up to the challenge as they limited the U.S. to 12 shots and only 2 were on goal (though I’m curious about that stat since it shows Wambach with one of those shots, but zero shots on goal; didn’t the keeper have to make a save to push the ball over the crossbar.  Isn’t that a shot on goal?).

So the defense was great and the offense didn’t produce too many shots.  That just leaves the midfield.  Cue the music because it was Musical Midfield during this game.  Rapinoe, Lloyd, Holiday, and Brian were the starters.  Amy Rodriquez came into the game in the 58th minute for Brian.  So A-Rod went to forward and Press dropped back to her less than desired position in midfield. Nine minutes later, Wambach game in for Press.  So Wambach takes A-Rod’s place up front and A-Rod dropped back into the midfield position.  Luckily, after that it was Morgan for Leroux, forward to forward, so that the midfield musical chairs stopped.  If those are the substitutions to be made, I question the order.  Switch the first two so that the midfield has some consistency for longer stretches.

A midfield that nearly everybody agrees is underperforming.  The reasons for that underperformance seem to vary depending on who you ask.  My opinion, and you can call me names if you want, is that the problem doesn’t lay with Holiday.  Yes, she went to my high school (well after I graduated) so you can say that I’m blinded because of it, but it also means that I have kept a close eye on her. Holiday has a high soccer IQ, is adaptable, is strong, and has a smooth touch on the ball, but if you want the most out of her, I think she needs to be in that #10 playmaker position.  That’s the position she plays for Kansas City to spectacular results.  League MVP, League Golden Boot in 2013, League Champion in 2014, Championship game MVP in 2014, one of the historical League leaders in goals and assists, all while being one of the most fouled players in the league.  Yes, she’s doing a serviceable job as the holding midfielder, but I don’t think you get everything out of her and the team in that position.  I know, I know, who plays there if not Holiday?  Boxx or Brian and I probably go with Brian only because of the limited amount of time Boxx has played lately.  Then I put Heather O’Reilly on the right flank and let her run up and down on the opponent’s left midfielder.

This is where I seem to differ from a lot of the other opinions out there.  I’ve seen comments that only Rapinoe is attacking.  From my perspective, that’s because she’s not passing when she should and trying to do too much.  Tony DiCicco has said similar statements at times during the broadcasts so there’s at least one that might agree with me, but that’s not the majority of the opinion.  I love Rapinoe, but I think she needs to be shouldering some of the blame of the poorly performing midfield.  She’s taken the criticism I normally reserved for Lloyd.

I would like to see the team start like this 4-4-2 arrangement:
---------- Solo ---------
--- Krieger --- Sauerbrunn --- Johnston --- Klingenberg ---
--------- Brian --------
--- O’Reilly ------ Heath ---
--------- Holiday --------
--- Rodriquez ------ Press ---

Wambach, Press, and/or Morgan on as super-duper subs and Rapinoe/Lloyd as needed for midfield subs.  Still not sure why O’Hara isn’t playing at all, but given how well the way the back four played against Sweden, I would stick with them until they are either hurt or completely exhausted.

Here’s my logic on that lineup.

Leroux’s pace and strength are impressive, but Press is a natural goal scorer and seems to be in better form right now.  I like Rodriquez’s connection with Holiday from their experience together over the years and now as teammates with Kansas City and would take advantage of that.  Morgan being fit to play is different than being fit to play 90 minutes, which is still further different than being able to play 90 minutes in the World Cup.  I also feel like I see a lot of Heath in for Holiday substitutions and I think that is a waste of vision and skill.  I’ve always liked their combination play in the games where they are in together and I would take advantage of the connection and vision too.

I’m going by memory here, but pre-Wambach in the Sweden game, I feel like there were more quick restarts on free kicks than after she came into the game.  I can recall one free kick shortly after she came in that was probably 40 yards from goal and close to the sideline.  Instead of starting quickly, the kick became a skewed corner kick.  Maybe it is just people seeing things differently, but there could be something to the statement of a tactical change when Wambach is on the field that isn’t necessarily a good change.

That lineup is never going to happen though and would guess that it will be very similar to what we saw against Sweden.  Might see Rampone or O’Hara to get them some minutes in case they are needed later in the tournament and likely see Morgan come off the bench again.  With a win or draw, they will advance and even a loss could be okay depending on the other results, so I don’t anticipate too many drastic changes for Tuesday night’s game against Nigeria.  Though I’ve read that they have issues with set pieces so Wambach may get the start again to try and get an early set piece goal and put Nigeria playing from behind.  I think it’s a 2-0 win and they advance as the #1 seed from the group.

Friday, June 12, 2015

Women's World Cup - USA vs Australia

Due to a Megan Rapinoe brace and a third goal by Christen Press, the United States Women's Team overcame a less than stellar start to beat Australia 3-1. A 3-1 victory that has them leading their group and the seemingly overwhelming media narrative is that the United States team is no longer the dominant team and that they are being caught and passed by the other nations in the world.  This is both true and false. The other countries (some of them anyway) are starting to catch up to the talent and athleticism of the American women.  Germany and France in particular are in good form and have the ability to beat the United States.  Japan as well. Even the host team Canada has shown they are getting closer to routinely competing with the United States.

And yet, the United States played a good feisty Australian team, played less than they are capable, and still walked away with a win.  This team is deep at all positions.  The only spot that has any kind of real concern is with a holding midfielder and nobody is a natural in that position.  Shannon Boxx does a good job with it, Morgan Brian is getting there, and Lauren Holiday is using her talent and soccer IQ to do the best she can with it. Though I think most would agree that she is a much better and more natural attacking midfielder.

So what went wrong in the start of the game?

Of the 14 players for the United States, five of them were in their first World Cup and it showed at times. I watched Julie Johnston play in the U-20 World Cup in Japan and she was great.  She's done a great job leading up to the World Cup.  I think the early pressure by Australia caused her to change the way she plays and started relying on blasting the ball as soon as she could.  Even when she had plenty of time.  That will be fixed by Friday night against Sweden.  Oh, and sitting on the bench is ageless wonder Christie Rampone if needed.

Pia Sundhage has caught some grief in the last couple days for her comments about her former team, but I tend to agree with some of them. Wambach would be better served coming off the bench this time around and let Leroux and Rodriguez start because they are both in good form.  Especially while Morgan gets her legs under her after having not played much this year with her injury.  Or even Press up top with O'Reilly as the winger because Press has a nose for the goal and O'Reilly will keep the width better. Wambach affects the team's decisions on restarts.  There were times during the game where the team played long set pieces instead of quick restarts that might have served them better. Set pieces have always been a key part of the U.S. team, both men and women, but there's a time to go quick too and I think the team errs to the side of set pieces when Wambach is on the field.

Defensively, I'm still surprised that O'Hara is sitting given that she played every single minute of the last Olympics, but I think we'll see her before this World Cup finishes.  I think Coach Ellis and the U.S. look at this as a marathon of 7 games and using the team depth against the other countries so I think Rampone gets the start against Sweden.

Pia is also right about Lloyd and Solo.  Lloyd is a scoring midfielder.  I've argued before that is because Lloyd looks to shoot first and hold onto the ball, often at the expense of looking for teammates who have been options.  Since 2011, Lloyd has a 3:1 goal to assist ratio while Holiday has a 1:2.5 goal to assist ratio during that same time.  Lauren has shown she can score goals at all levels, but she looks to get her teammates involved as well.  Lloyd's role of hold the ball and shoot first, pass second was taken by Rapinoe during the game and she scored two goals so maybe that's further proof that I don't know what I'm saying.

Solo...  We've all read the news articles about her.  I've read her book.  She seems to be a complete headcase off the field, but within those white lines, she's the best goalie in the world.  One of the things that has bothered me about nearly every article I've read about the U.S. vs Australia game is the narrative that Australia would have easily beaten the U.S. if Solo didn't bail them out.  There are 11 players on the field and the goalkeeper is a vital part of that and is part of the game plan. As a defender, if you have a goalie of Solo's caliber, you play a little different than if my 80 year old grandmother was playing behind you.  You can call it bailing out the defense, but I think it's just a vital cog in the game plan.

What is concerning for the U.S. moving forward are the two yellow cards given to Holiday and Rapinoe.  Were they fouls? Yes. Were they cards? I don't think so.  Given that a second card by either of them results in a game suspension all the way until the quarterfinal round, both are going to need to be careful with their play.





Three goals for, one against, top of the group and the world is crashing in around them?  Don't believe that narrative.

Monday, June 8, 2015

2015 Women's World Cup

Tomorrow, the United States Women's National Team begins its quest to do what the women's team has failed to do since 1999.

Win that trophy.
<--------

Unlike the Men's National Team, the World Cup is the expectation for the women's team and despite its successes in the Olympics in recent years against essentially the same competition, the World Cup is still the more desired trophy. The team's failure to win the coveted trophy has been discussed at great length by pundits after every World Cup comes to a close with the U.S. team not hoisting it.  There are reasons given about the rest of the world catching up to the speed and athleticism of the United States, the flaw here and the flaw there, and even issues with coaches selection of which goalie to play.  To me, it comes down to proof that it's a hard damn trophy to win, even if you're the team that is favored to win it.

The United States is in the so-called "Group of Death," having to face Australia, Sweden, and Nigeria, ranked 2, 10, 5, and 33, respectively.  The United States' group schedule looks like this:
Monday, June 8
United States vs. Australia (Winnipeg), 7:30 p.m. (Fox Sports 1)

Friday, June 12
United States vs. Sweden (Winnipeg), 8 p.m. (FOX)

Tuesday, June 16
Nigeria vs. United States (Vancouver), 8 p.m. (FOX)

There are the high profile players on the team who seem to be getting most of the press.  Solo, Wambach, Morgan, Leroux, and even Lloyd look to be on most of the magazine covers. I think this World Cup is going to hinge on Sauerbrunn, Johnston, Klingenberg, Chalupny, Rapinoe, and Holiday. Solo is the best goalkeeper in the world and those other four are some of the best finishers. This World Cup is going to hinge on what goes on between all of the headliners. I don't think Rampone is going to get the same kinds of minutes and Sauerbrunn has slowly become one of the best center defenders in the world.

I also think that Lloyd's decision making in the midfield is going to be key.  If she picks the right times to take her shots, and she will take her shots, this could go very well for the team. If she doesn't take the right time to take her shots, which she is prone to do from time to time, there's going to be some wasted opportunities.

I think this is the year for them to finally bring the Cup back to the States, but I don't think it's going to be easy.  Like the pundits have all said, "the world is catching up."

Friday, July 11, 2014

World Cup - ARG vs NED

I'm not sure what to say about this game.  As offensive as the Germany vs Brazil game was for the Germans, this game was more like a game of cat and mouse.  Which is why it went to penalty kicks.  While the game didn't produce any goals through the duration of regular time and the overtime periods, it was probably a better played game than the other semifinal.  It wasn't as memorable though.

Due to it happening on a gymnastics night, I caught much of the game streaming live from my computer.  As I realized that it was going into overtime, I decided that I needed to start towards the gym.  So I finished what I was doing and headed out.  When I got to the car none of the local sports stations were carrying the game, so I turned on the ESPNWatch app, put in one of my headphones, and listened to it while I drove.  When I was about 10 minutes from the gym, the game had just gone into penalties and I decided that listening to PKs was ridiculous.  So I pulled into the parking lot of an abandoned country club and watched the PKs from my phone.  Watched the final kick and then was right back on the road to the gym.  Amazing what technology has done for the ability to watch games now.

So the final is set.  Germany vs Argentina.  The team that has scored 17 goals this tournament (4 against Portugal, the #4 ranked team coming into the tournament, and 7 against Brazil, the #3 ranked team coming into the tournament) and survived the "group of death" versus the team that has scored 9 goals and survived a group with an average ranking of 36.  Knockout round competition has been a little bit closer for the two teams, but I have to think that the hard path taken by the German squad has better prepared them.  Nobody expected a 6 goal drubbing of Brazil by Germany or that Spain (the #1 ranked team coming in) and Portugal wouldn't make it out of the group stage.  I guess that's why they play the games.

World Cup - GER vs BRA

Going into this game, based on what had been going on during the rest of the tournament, this looked to be good game, even without  Neymar and Silva.  It wasn't.  Really, not even for the first 11 minutes.  It seemed like the perfect start for Germany after that first goal.  The second one looked like a back breaker.  You never want to say that a World Cup level team "gave up," but that was the look that Brazil had at only the 23rd minute. 
 
Six minutes later and a world class drubbing was complete.  I've never watched a World Cup game where a team looked so completely overmatched.  Their spacing was horrible, defenders didn't close on the ball, and their general effort was poor.  Things improved slightly after the half-time break, but even that effort was short lived.
 
Maybe Dr. Evil says it best...
 


Thursday, July 10, 2014

World Cup - US vs Belgium

Gutted.  That's the only way I can describe my feeling after the loss.  Not because I thought the United States were going to win for most of the game, but because they toyed with my emotions once again.  They gave me hope that they were going to do the improbable and pull out the victory when it looked like there was no way it could be accomplished.  I recorded a replay of the game so I could rewatch it, but I still can't bring myself to watch it.  I haven't reached the point where I'm willing to put myself through the roller coaster ride again.

First, it was the miss by Wondo.  You know, the one that would have won it in extra time of regulation.

This is a guy that has thrived on being in the right place at the right time.  And yet, that's about as poor a strike as I've seen out of him.  I'm still not sure how he missed it that badly.

Then, they gave up the early overtime goal.  And then another.  2-nil.  That's it, right?  At that point, I nearly walked away from the game because I didn't think it would be possible for them to come back from a two goal deficit with so little time remaining.

And yet, Klinsmann puts in the young kid with almost no experience at this level and what does he do?  He scores a goal on his first touch of the game.

Let's be honest, it wasn't a clean touch.  He mis-hit the ball.  He didn't catch it as flush as he would have liked, but that might be why it found the back of the net.

Then there was that absolutely stunning set piece, thirty yards from the goal.  A set piece so amazing that I can't imagine even working on it in practice, much less attempting it any kind of game, but especially a World Cup game.  The courage it takes to dial up that play in that moment is something that I hope I never forget about watching the game.

The slightest different touch by Dempsey and this set piece would be forever described in World Cup history as one of the greatest set pieces ever instead of one of the greatest set piece attempts.

I have two takeaways from the game.  My first takeaway from the game and, by extension, the USMNT in general, is related to something I read on the MLS Matchday app (I assume it's available somewhere online, but haven't found it) about "game states."
1. This was the World Cup of game states

The analytics community is big on "game states," as they should be (I say "they" because I was an English major and actually don't remember how to do anything beyond long division). "Game state" means – broadly – what the score of the game is, and how it affects how the two teams play.

In other words, the US played much differently down 1-0 against Portugal than they did when up 2-1 vs. the same. And we played much differently down 1-0 vs. Germany in the group stage – an acceptable result that was likely to seal our advancement – than we did when down 1-0 to Belgium in today's game.

"Just hope," Tim Howard explained on the air afterward. "When we changed over we just said let's try and get a goal and if we get a goal we put them under pressure. And at 2-1 we did that. Dream falls short but like I said this is an incredible group and I'll never forget this night."

No one else should forget it, either, because the US were brilliant in attack once down a goal (and even better once down two). That follows the same pattern against Portugal, as well as the desperation push once Ghana equalized.

Here's the graph of US shots from the first 105 minutes:

And here's the last 15, once desperation kicked in:

In case you don't want to count: that's seven shots each.

Part of this is Belgium falling victim to game states themselves. But the bigger part of it is Klinsmann taking the shackles off and dropping pragmatism for attacking verve, something which should happen earlier and more often going forward. This US is a very, very talented team – one of the dozen or so best in the world. It's time to stop playing like we're the underdog at all times and actually deliver the promise of proactive soccer.
 Every time I saw the US perform poorly in this World Cup, it was because they reverted (despite promises from Klinsmann when he was hired that he would change the strategy), back to the US team that played not to lose.  When I watch the USWNT, their tactics are different.  If one goal wins the game, five is surely not enough.  They never, as far as I've seen, take the foot off the gas.  They have the best goalie in the world, a spectacular defense, an imposing midfield, and a wealth of forwards to finish.  I don't understand why the USMNT doesn't have the same mentality.  They have one of the best goalies in the world, a solid defense, a midfield that includes one of the best in the world, and excellent finishers.  So why does the women's team continue to take it to their opponents, while the men's team tries not to get beat too badly.  Like the writer above stated, the men's team needs to stop playing like the underdog and play like the winners we nearly saw from them at the end of the Belgium game.

My second takeaway?  Tim Howard is a beast.  I told you he was my man of the match in the group stages and he didn't make me regret that in the Belgium game.  The only reason the team had the slightest of chances at the end of overtime is because Howard had one of the greatest games ever by a goalkeeper in a World Cup game.  Wonder what all those saves look like at one time? 




Thank you Tumblr for the gifs...