Showing posts with label McAuley. Show all posts
Showing posts with label McAuley. Show all posts

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Indy Eleven 2026 Season Recap & 2027 Outlook

I normally give myself a couple of weeks after Indy's departure from the season, but I felt like working on evaluating this season and looking forward to next so we're bumping this up a little earlier than normal. Let's start out with the good news from the 2026 season.

* crickets *

Anybody?

* crickets *

Oh wait, I have a few things.

  • McAuley surpassed 100 games, becoming the longest tenured (by games) coach in club history and providing some consistency to a position that has been an absolute turnstyle over the years. 
  • Blake overtook club legend Eamon Zayed as the top goal scorer in team history. 
  • Quinn became the league leader in assists. He also surpassed the 100 games played mark to give the current team 3 players and a coach in the Century Club at the same time. 
  • Lindley became the first Indy player to surpass the 10,000-minute mark for the team. 
  • Rendon scored 12 goals across all competitions (10 in league play to finish the regular season tied for 11th in the USL Championship). 
  • Hafferty was an absolutely stellar acquisition late in the season.

The bad news is much easier to find. For the second year in a row, Indy had a chance to squeak into the playoffs in the last game of the year after some results went their way. However, just like last year, Indy failed to do so, losing in Charleston 1-nil. Indy only had the ball 18% of time, only made 142 passes (62 of which were considered "long" - 44%), but managed 14 shots with 4 on target from that limited amount of time with the ball. Given Indy's available players (game day roster included just 4 field players, one of which was a 15-year Academy player), McAuley came out in a highly defensive-minded 5-4-1 lineup with the apparent plan to limit Charleston chances (which was moderately successful), steal some opportunities (check), and be there at the end to try and steal a win (check). All things considered, the final game was about as good as they could do, but it wasn't enough. 

As I mentioned after the Louisville game after Louisville won their midweek game to clinch a first round home playoff game, the frustration of being an Indy Eleven fan is that even in a down year for Louisville (which included an unprecedented 4-game losing streak), they still managed to find enough results and have enough results go their way that they still ended in 4th place with a guaranteed home game. Indy, conversely (at that point of the schedule) were 90-minutes away from being eliminated from the playoffs despite having a 6-point advantage ahead of Miami with 2 games in hand just 5 weeks prior. A spectacular run-of-form from Miami, a continued string of injuries for Indy, and 1 point from their final 6 games left Indy in desperation mode headed to Charleston. Indy's early lost points from winning positions (more on that in a minute), their four-game losing streak in the middle of the season, and the absolute abysmal results to finish the year (1 point from the final 7 games) meant that they ended the season about where I thought they would be preseason; hovering around the playoff line.

Going back through some of my preseason discussions with people, John Morrisey stated, "There are enough mediocre teams that the 8 seed is on the table, but I struggle to make the argument for anything higher than that." That, my friends, is why he's so well known. Dude called it based only on the roster and some insight I gave him about what I saw in preseason exhibition games. My response was "I share your pessimism. I don't see how this team makes the playoffs, particularly if any of the veteran midfielders have to miss time." Seems like I knew what I was talking about too. As the injuries to the veterans piled up, the results flatlined. 

The starting lineup for the last game against Charleston was, by far, the most egregious version of it, with 5 defenders (Rasheed, Barry, Herbert, Craig, & Kibunguchy), 2 who have been playing wing backs throughout the season (Quinn & Hafferty), and a defensive midfielder who has been converted from a defender (O'Brien), but Indy's roster and tactics all season seemed to be based a lot on not conceding as many goals this year as last. That part was successful (56 last, 47 this year), but, conversely, Indy also didn't score as many goals either (55 last, 44 this year), still finishing the season with a negative goal differential across all competitions. Indy played to grind out games by defending and counter attacking. Sometimes that worked, sometimes that almost worked, and other times they beat themselves.

Much like 2025, the 2026 season was riddled with missed opportunities. Indy lost a significant number of points from winning positions, including 5 league games where they conceded in the 85th minute or later. In hindsight, the two games against Miami are arguably the most disheartening because a better result in even one of those games sends Indy to the postseason (assuming I'm doing my math correctly). 

  • March 28 draw vs Hartford (88' - O'Brien Own Goal) - 2 points lost
  • April 4 draw vs Pittsburgh (90') - 2 points lost
  • April 19 draw vs Birmingham (89') - 2 points lost
  • May 16 USL Cup "draw" vs Fort Wayne (90'+1') - win in shootout
  • June 13 loss vs Pittsburgh (90'+2') - 1 point lost 
  • August 9 draw vs Hartford (74') - 2 points lost
  • October 3 draw vs Loudoun (90'+5' - Farr) - 2 points lost
  • October 10 loss vs Tampa Bay (85' & 90'+2' for good measure) - 2 points lost

In 2025, Indy finished the season in 9th place with 35 points and a 10W-5D-15L record in league play.

In 2026, Indy finished the season in 9th place with 34 points and a 9W-7D-14L record in league play. 

"Deja vu all over again."

Last year, Indy had a 5W-3D-10L record on the road across all competitions, but they did even worse this year with an astonishingly garbage 1W-5D-11L record across all competitions away from Carroll Stadium. Indy were reasonably effective at home, despite the terrible turf, but Indy couldn't buy a result on the road. Indy's lone victory on the road this year was a 1-nil win against Sporting JAX, the worst team in the league, thanks to a 90'+2' own goal. If you can't get any results on the road, you have to be absolutely perfect at home and Indy wasn't that. Whoever works on the scheduling next year for Indy really needs to pay attention to the homestretch of games. This year, Indy was on the road in 4 of their last 5 (0W-1D-4L); in 2025, they traveled in 6 of the last 9 (losing all 6).

Looking forward to 2027, unless something drastically changes (more on that later), then I don't see Indy being anything beyond what they have been recently. A middle to low end of the table team who might squeak into the playoffs and then lose their first playoff game on the road.

Here are my thoughts when looking towards next season.

Looking to 2027

Stadium

Until an actual plan from the team or Ersal gets announced for what they intend to do now that the Eleven Park site is mired under the history of being a former cemetery with an unknown amount of human remains still located on the site, Carroll Stadium can be expected to be the team's unfortunate home field. And until they announce it (probably in conjunction with an an IBJ article), nobody else is going to know the plan. Players and coaches have complained about Carroll Stadium's turf since the beginning, and a replacement project in 2022 did very little to quell those complaints. Fans have complained about the amenities. A large track surrounds the entire field, pushing fans further from the action and periodically catching a player by surprise as their cleats slide out from under them and they find themselves on their ass. As I said last year, "American Soccer's Greatest Dive Bar" is losing its charm. Despite what announced attendance may tell you, actual attendance from my perspective continues to drop. The midweek games look horrendous on camera.

I know I'm in a minority of the outspoken fans on this, but I know there's also a low-key agreement with me by some too. Until I hear a better plan from the team and the ownership group, I will continue to argue that expanding the "championship stadium" listed in the Grand Park Master Plan to be large enough to support an Indy Eleven USL Premier level team (and meeting U.S. Soccer's First Division requirements) is the right plan. It has the ability to consolidate the entirety of the Indy Eleven infrastructure into a single location since the team's training facilities are already located there, the Academy train there, and the USL W team train and play there. From rumors, the smaller stadium in the Master Plan allows for Indy to meet the requirements to have a women's team in the USL Super League, which was supposed to have already happened in 2025 until the Mayor Hogsett/MLS fiasco started and pulled the Eleven Park rug out from under the team. Make the stadium a bit bigger with the ability to expand further and condense everybody into the location where Ersal and Indy Eleven are already managing the facilities. I fully believe that whatever fans you lose from the Indy/southside areas will be more than made up by new north side fans and/or promotions with soccer tournaments that allow youth players to come to games. Can you imagine a weekend soccer tournament at Grand Park with an Indy Eleven game on Saturday night where hundreds/thousands of young soccer players and their families can attend the game with a reasonable add-on to the tournament cost? Indy Eleven attendance numbers might actually be accurate and the atmosphere might improve to the early days of the team.

I've spelled out why this makes sense to me (Eleven Park at Grand Park) and until somebody explicitly tells me a different, better plan, it's going to continue to be my opinion.

Yes, I know Mayor Hogsett and MLS are still a thing. I took their MLS team and stadium survey. I still don't believe Indy is their first choice. 


Coach
Don Thompson Photography
I've had enough conversations with Coach McAuley now to know that he wants to come back. I also suspect that despite the lack of playoff appearances, he is probably getting offers from other teams. Maybe not high level teams, but maybe he is. He and I haven't talked about that. 

What I said last year stays true this year. "I fully expect McAuley to be back next year, trying to overcome the limitations that are set on Indy Eleven coaches with players. I don't think McAuley did enough to warrant being fired," but a second season not making the playoffs does begin to start a fire under his seat.  

What I don't know is how next year will be any different. I'll get into the players next, but if you assume a majority of this year's players return, in part because of financial limitations, but also part of the reason I think McAuley wants to return is that the club needs some consistency. Sign players, develop those players, and get better. Unless you have the financial backing to go out and buy talent, you have to accept that the seasons are going to swing back and forth between maximizing your available talent to make a playoff appearance and succumbing to injuries and failing to make the playoffs because the overall depth isn't there to compete week in and week out with the top teams in the league. 

Given the operational constraints of the club (stadium, budgets, etc.), the fact that McAuley wants to be here to try and improve the club says a lot about Sean the man.

Sidenote discussion: If/when McAuley gets tired of being in Indy or he gets let go, I would be intrigued by a Eamon Zayed-led Indy Eleven. I know from talking to him over the years that he would like to be here and has tried a couple of times when Indy has been between coaches. Z has been a successful League One coach and it might be time for someone to take a chance on him as a Championship coach.

Players

After a second consecutive season where Indy just missed out on participating in the postseason, you might think that there will be, again, an overhaul of the roster. I keep harping on the budget, but with that constraint, the current budget-friendly contracts might get renewed. 

After last year, McAuley stated that he was going to bring in players for 2026 that were younger and hungrier. I think he did that, but what we also found out was that while this year's roster was younger and hungrier than last year's, the younger showed to not be experienced or talented enough. As a result, McAuley had to rely on the veterans more who all became injured late in the season because they had to play so many minutes.

Last month, I wrote about the possibility of Indy, either willingly or by relegation once the USL Premier league starts and pro/rel enters the American chat, drops down to League One. Indy only had moderate success against the League One sides they played this year, and I stated at one point that Indy might be a mid- to low-Championship side, but might be an upper- to mid-League One side. I've said a few times in recent months that Indy had the lowest budget in the league at $1.2M. I recently found out that one of the top spending teams in League One was Boise who spent...$1.2M. 

It's starting to feel like I know what I'm talking about.

As I mentioned in my "Could Indy Eleven's Inaugural Season Been Different?" article from a few years ago, Peter Wilt let me know that Indy's inaugural player budget was...$1.2M. I'm nearly positive that the salary has gone up over the years, but for whatever reason, it has come back down. Actually, I do have a bit of a theory.

At best, Indy's on-field performance has been spotty over the years and definitely not consistent top-of-the-league results. As the team continues to be stuck in mid-table seasons, more and more people have stopped buying tickets. Fewer people in stands means less ticket sales, less merch sales, and less concession sales. As a result, the club has to try and find the money in other ways, which is typically through sponsorships and ads. However, as fan attendance decreases, corporate sponsors see less value in providing the same amount of money to reach fewer people. As a result, they begin to decrease their dollars. With decreasing fan money and decreasing sponsor money, the club has no choice but to decrease their player budget. Decreased player budget means that the players brought in are "hungrier," "younger," or maybe "aging out veterans" that aren't able to get consistently good results. More fans stop coming to games, sponsors spend less, budget decreases. Rinse and repeat until 1) club fails entirely, 2) drops down a league (soon a possibility in the USL pyramid), or 3) somebody comes in Wrexham style and infuses a new about of capital. While the 3rd doesn't always guarantee success, the jolt of money does make it feel like the team is trying to do something and fans and sponsors might come back too. 

Feel like this could be Indy's scenario. Minus the infusion of capital, which doesn't seem like is going to come from Ersal, and despite additional owners being listed on the website, none of those other guys are ever mentioned as being significant financial providers for the team. If I'm honest, that leaves options 1 and 2 as viable possibilities.

Until that happens, Indy's going to probably be towards the bottom of the budget spenders in the league with somewhere in the mid- to low-table results. With all that as a backdrop, here are what I think happens to this year's roster in the off-season.

Gone:

  1. Okello - That's obvious. He was transferred to Lexington in the deal that brough Henry-Scott and Hafferty to Indy late in the season. McAuley thought highly of Okello, but I doubt it's enough to re-sign him.
  2. Neidlinger - One of Indy's Academy products, and Indy's youngest goal scorer in team history, but Logan's defensive deficiencies and Indy's desperation to get results forced the team to find somebody in his place. Neidlinger's time in Fort Wayne FC in League One seems like it might have been good for him. I suspect his was on a 2-year deal, which is ending this year and while I don't think Indy will re-sign him, I wouldn't be surprised if FWFC sign him for next season.
  3. Williams, K - he could never find minutes in McAuley's lineup (just 40 minutes in 4 league games, but he did find just under 400 minutes in the various Cup games) and eventually was loaned to Detroit FC. Those kinds of guys rarely make it back for another season, unless he had a guaranteed 2-year deal.
  4. Thomas - Played 107 minutes across 4 games. Unless he's on a guaranteed 2-year deal or is making the league minimum (which could be possible), I would suspect he's not around next season.
  5. Gavilanes - Only time he broke into the lineup was during the USOC games. Otherwise, he had a very noticeable 0 minutes played in 0 games. Like Neidlinger above, Gavilanes was loaned to a League One side with Union Omaha and seems to be having a good run there, including being named to the USL Prinx Tires Cup Team of the Tournament. Most of his time has been in USL League One (or Miami FC, which arguably was like a League One team those seasons), so that may just be his level. Won't be surprised if he signs with a team in League One, but I doubt he returns to Indy.
    Sidenote: that team has 5 players with Indy Eleven ties. Not sure what that means, but it is an interesting fact.

Possibly Gone:

  1. Craig - I'm not confident on this placement though. He was brought into the team, presumably for depth, but had to play a much more active role due to injuries to the other players. Craig battled his own injuries and just turned 34. Not saying he can't return, because he generally looked good most of the season, but he's also at that age when I could see him hang up the boots. This may hinge on whether he was on a 2-year deal.
  2. Hogan - No idea what to think here. I had Hogan in this exact same category last offseason because he was non-existent in the final third of the 2025 season. However, coming into this year, it was looking like he was going to be one of the starting center backs until his season-ending injury in preseason. If he was on a 2-year contract, it would be expiring. So I have no idea what may happen with Pat.
  3. Don Thompson Photography
    Rendon - Not because McAuley doesn't want him, but because I wouldn't be surprised if other teams with deeper pockets have expressed interest in having him. Even if he has contract remaining for Indy, for the right dollar amount, I could be gone. Where Indy's offense comes from if that happens will have to be sorted out with other signings this off-season.
  4. Kizza - Something just tells me he might not be back.
  5. Quinn - Dude's still playing at a high level, but he will be 35 years old when the season kicks off next year. He's already been doing some coaching with the Academy team. Is next year the year he transitions to the first team? If he's not ready to retire to the sideline, I would place him in the Probably Returning group because he's started setting down roots here in Indy and wants to be here. Don't think he pulls a Crash Davis-style end of his illustrious USL career to get one more season somewhere other than Indy. 
  6. *Hafferty and Henry-Scott - I had them in the Probably Returning category because I had mis-remembered the deal. I, correctly, remembered that Okello was a transfer to Lexington, but incorrectly remembered it being the same for Hafferty and Henry-Scott. As Anonymous indicated in the comments, section, they were actually loaned to Indy. So I'll put them back into the Possibly Gone category, but if money becomes available, don't be surprised if Hafferty is announced as a signing.

Probably Returning:

Literally everybody else. Due to the budget-friendly nature of this year's roster, there's limited risk to keeping everybody else, even if the team didn't make the playoffs. It will all come down to what pieces get added around them on whether this core of players repeats this year's meh season or can over-achieve. 
  1. Barry
  2. Blake
  3. Charles-Cook
  4. Dick
  5. Hafferty (see above)
  6. Henry-Scott (see above)
  7. Herbert
  8. Kibunguchy
  9. Lindley
  10. Mesanvi
  11. Mitrano
  12. O'Brien
  13. Omar
  14. Rasheed
  15. Sharp
  16. Sing
  17. White
Something that Coach McAuley has stated few times that has resonated with me is that, "In football, if you stay the same, you're probably getting worse. So we need to improve next year and improve again and just keep improving."

Looking at that potential returning roster, the obvious question that comes to mind is, "how does that team improve from a 9th place finish in the table with the majority of the roster remaining while potentially losing 4 of the more important pieces of it?" 

I really don't know.

But that's where we find ourselves as Indy fans. Stuck in a stadium that we already left once to go to Lucas Oil Stadium but boomeranged back into and then were told we would be in a fancy new Eleven Park stadium more than a year ago (that sucks to say after sitting in a tent in 2023 for the groundbreaking), all with the lowest player budget in USL Championship that is rivaled by at least one team in League One.

Thursday, July 30, 2026

An upcoming Century Club member


A member of the Indy Eleven will join the Century Club in the very near future. No, I'm not talking about Aodhan Quinn, though he should reach the milestone in the game at home against Louisville City on August 22nd. However, a different person will beat him to the punch to joining the Century Club membership.

Photo: Don Thompson Photography
When Indy Eleven take the field at Carroll Stadium for the Sunday evening game against Hartford Athletic, Sean McAuley will officially become the longest tenured coach in Indy Eleven men's history. The Hartford game will be McAuley's 100th game, while Martin Rennie was officially the man in charge for 99 games (he did have one more in-season unofficial friendly game against Detroit City, but those games don't count to players or fans totals, so they don't count for the coaches either). 

How is that possible you might initially ask? Rennie famously quit in the postgame discussion with Greg Rakestraw while in his 4th season, while McAuley is only midway through his 3rd season? Well, McAuley is helped by a good run in the U.S. Open Cup, but also Rennie's 3rd season was the shortened 2020 COVID year. So McAuley has managed to get there in fewer seasons thanks to the season circumstances and some better results in non-league play. 

Regardless, like a few members of this current version of the Indy Eleven men's team, McAuley will find himself at the top of the pile as it relates to games. So I thought it would be a good time to remind fans (and others) what Coach McAuley has achieved in his tenure.

As of right today, McAuley has a 40W-22D-36L record, good for a 40.8% win rate and a 63.3% positive result (win or draw) rate. Rennie's rates were slightly higher (46.0% and 65.0%, respectively), as weas Hankinson's win/draw rate (70.0%), but both were extremely buoyed by a single season. Hankinson's 2016 season had a positive result rate of 81.1% and Rennie's 2019 season had a rate of 72.5% in large part because they had undefeated home records in those seasons. However, Hankinson's 2017 numbers dropped to 57.6% and Rennie's final two seasons dropped to 56.3% and 50.0%. McAuley, conversely, has hovered just under or over 60% for all of his seasons. On a season-by-season basis, McAuley's teams have achieved positive results 67.5% (2024), 59.5% (2025), and 61.9% (2026) of the time. 

Note: both of Hankinson's and Rennie's top seasons included one of the unofficial friendly matches (Pachuca and Detroit City, respectively) and I have included those in my numbers. 

On a Points Per Match perspective, McAuley ranks second to Rennie (1.57 to 1.45). 
On a Goals For per match, McAuley overtakes Rennie 1.44 to 1.36. 

There's a trend when it comes to Indy Eleven coaches. Hankinson's 2016 has been the fan's torch bearer for Indy Eleven men's successful seasons. An undefeated home season. The team's only hardware. That 2016 season has been how all subsequent teams have been judged. Outside of that one season, though, it has been Rennie and McAuley who have been the most consistently successful coaches in the Indy Eleven team history. Depending on the stat, one of those two coaches is the leader. 

Let that sink in. Despite having the lowest player budget in the league this season and against, arguably better competition than those other coaches (Rennie's teams played against the MLS2 teams and Hankinson coached in the NASL, and today's USL Championship is definitely better from top to bottom than what the other Indy teams competed against), Coach McAuley has been the more consistently winning coach in team history. Of the coaches that have had successful tenures in Indy, he is matching or bettering those other season's statistics, including a positive goal differential. 

Photo: Don Thompson Photography
I don't know what McAuley's or the team's plan is for his future in Indianapolis. I think he wants to be back, but in the world of USL, the owners and other teams and a carrousel of players makes it nearly impossible to know what Indy Eleven will look like from year-to-year. If he returns, Indy will continue to have a coach that knows the value of the supporters and will work, with the constraints of what he is given, to provide a team that works hard to give the fans, particularly at home, a winning result. McAuley, above any other coach for the team, understands the value of the Brickyard Battalion and supporters in general, and their connection to the team, players, and culture. McAuley has done what he can do to get the players to understand what they mean to the community.

When I went back and listened to my recording of McAuley's very first meet-and-great with the fans in January 2024, I was struck by his response to Rakestraw's question about what "drew you to this job at this time in USL Championship":

"To start off, I looked at the opportunity. It is very much a MLS club, in the USL It wants to run like one, it wants to act like one, be like one. It has the supporters that can transition to one. And we're really comfortable being in the USL, the one thing we haven't done is won it. And that was attractive because I want to be the first one to do something where it's going to last a long time in the club's history. The other thing I was immediately attracted to was when I spoke to Greg and Ersal, and their vision of where they want the club to go in the future, that was really attractive to me also because their ambition is really strong and it sort of matched mine. And then the values that they have with the club and the supporters and what we want to achieve together, it sort of matched to be a perfect fit. And I looked at the playing squad. And they're pretty good. The returning players, we're really pleased with and then it was up to the staff, and again the ownership, to try and take us a little bit further, and they've done that in support of the new signings we've made. So we're really pleased where we are at the minute, it's not going to stop, everything that keeps progressing keeps progressing my initial reaction was strong and every day's getting stronger."

I would be curious to know how much of that statement McAuley still believes, but at nearly a century of games under his belt for Indy Eleven, I do know that I have valued every interaction I have had with him. I know he wants to make the team, the club, and the players better, and that he values the role that supporters (and guys like me in the media scrum) provide for building a club. 

McAuley is soon to be a welcome addition to the Century Club.

Tuesday, November 11, 2025

Indy Eleven 2025 Season Recap & 2026 Off-Season Outlook

I concluded the 2024 season recap with the following statement:

With a year under his belt, and a Top 4 finish in the conference, McAuley’s expectations for next season are going to go up. If other fans are like me, you would like to match those expectations, but history of the club has made that a difficult proposition. We have grown to accept that the setbacks happen just as frequently as the breakthroughs. However, the team improved from year 1 to year 2 under Rennie, and then did the same thing under Lowry (after the requisite setbacks in year 3 and 4 under Rennie…). 

Then wouldn't you know it, toward the end of August, as it started becoming clear that reality was deviating from expectations, I wrote an article about expectations, spelling out why it might be unreasonable for Indy to be burdened with the constant expectation that they be towards the top of the table. History has consistently shown that being at the top of the table is the exception not the norm for the team. Indy is more frequently a middle to bottom resident on the table, with only sporadic forays at the top, and even more infrequent and consistent participants in the league's postseason. 

This year proved to be no different. A Top 4 finish in league play and a run to a semifinal game in the U.S. Open Cup last year with a bulk of the key components of the roster returning this year gave rise to the expectation that Indy should once again be challenging for a league championship this year. As I indicated in my Expectation vs Reality article from when it was said to me, "Conflict arises when expectations exceed reality." 

As the injury bug began to rear its head, the club made no signings to help take the burden off the healthy players until September 3rd, when the team had no choice but to pick up a few loaned players from MLS NextPro teams. The club's expectations of being a top club had been met with "just making due" and budget issues until it could no longer do anything but try and find a few players to round out game day rosters. When the new players were immediately thrown into the starting lineup, it was made visible that Coach McAuley hadn't had enough players to help make game-to-game and in-game adjustments. Yet the loanees weren't enough to settle things and the team finished the final third of the season consistently inconsistent with a 4W-0D-6L record in the final 10 games, including a loss in the final game of the season against Orange County after the door had been opened for them to sneak into the playoffs with a win. Instead, Indy's defeat allowed Detroit to take the final spot in the Eastern Conference, who then took that opening and defeated Louisville in Louisville to bounce the Players' Shield winners in their earliest exit in the history of that club. Proving just how important it is to get into the playoffs in this league. In a one-off game, almost anything can happen.

Speaking about how anything can happen in a one-off game, that was how Indy found themselves out of the Jagermeister Cup as Indy lost to League One side Greenville Triumph after conceding a late goal in the 90th minute. After Greenville forced the Penalty Shootout, Sulte went the wrong way on every Greenville kick and Bryneus missed the team's 6th attempt, and Greenville moved on while Indy's season struggles continued. To that point, Indy had never trailed in the tournament and technically finished the tournament without an official loss, since the Greenville game is officially listed as a draw.

The theme of the 2025 season was missed opportunities. As I indicated in the Orange County recap, not counting the two games in the Jagermeister Cup where Indy conceded late goals that forced the team into penalty kicks, Indy lost 18 points from winning positions, most notably four games when Indy dropped points with just minutes (seconds?) remaining in the game:

  • April 5 draw North Carolina (90'+3') - 2 points lost
  • May 10 draw vs Sacramento (90'+6') - 2 points lost
  • June 21 loss vs Las Vegas (90') - 3 points lost
  • Aug 16 loss vs Loudoun (86') - 3 points lost
Indy also made life difficult for themselves in the Jagermeister Cup when they conceded late, the second of which meant that they were eliminated from the competition at home by a League One team.
  • June 28 "draw" vs Birmingham (90'+4') - win in PK Jagermeister
  • Aug 20 "draw" vs Greenville (90') - loss in PK Jagermeister

Indy's season could have been a lot different.

Coach McAuley has indicated a few times to me, "In football, if you stay the same, you're probably getting worse. So we need to improve next year and improve again and just keep improving."

2025 feels like a step backward from 2024 in many aspects. What happens this offseason could dictate whether 2026 is an improvement year or another backsliding year.

To that end, here are my thoughts when looking towards next season.

Looking to 2026

Stadium

Whatever I said last year about the stadium applies this year. What I said last year was that the stadium was in limbo, and fans didn't know what's going on. Nothing from that perspective has changed. Seemingly, outside of a couple of people, and I'm guessing even that number could be a stretch, nobody seems to know anything about the status of an Indy Eleven stadium. Or nobody is willing to tell me anything about the status of an Indy Eleven stadium. 

The lack of the stadium has meant the continued delay of a women's team, which lead to the departure of the club's most successful coach, persistent comments that the Carroll Stadium surface continues to be a difficult one to play on, and a more vocal frustration from fans who have been required to sit in "American Soccer's Greatest Dive Bar" that is losing its charm. Once a term of affection from fans, the idiosyncrasies of the stadium are starting to wear on fans.  

I have thoughts on the stadium. Coming soon.

Coach
A second season under Coach McAuley was still one of the more successful for an Indy Eleven coach, but reality didn't meet expectations. I don't think it matters. I fully expect McAuley to be back next year, trying to overcome the limitations that are set on Indy Eleven coaches with players. I don't think McAuley did enough to warrant being fired, I would guess a less-than-stellar second head coaching season doesn't have a lot of other teams trying to poach him, and I think he wants to be here. I hope he's back. I've enjoyed my experiences with him. 

I do think he will want to fix an issue that persisted into his second season. Last year, the 59 goals that the team scored were a club record setting total, but unfortunately, they conceded 56 goals. This year, the totals were nearly identical, with the team scoring 55 goals, but they conceded 56 across all competitions. In league play, the team was a -8 in goal differential. Coach is going to want to fix that, which I think he'll have the chance to do when he stays in Indy next season.

Players

I've had relatively decent success guessing which players will be returning in recent years, but when the players that I think could and should return struggled to ninth place in the table, this is one of those years where I could be completely wrong. I think Coach McAuley intends to bring back a core group of this year's team and then bring in new, younger and hungrier, players. Younger players looking to make a name for themselves or older players desperate to show they still have what it takes. McAuley's said some version of that to me and he's also said it on Soccer Saturday. The unknown for me is who he considers to be the most necessary of the "core."

The following is based entirely on my own opinions, but here are the players from this year's roster that I can envision being somewhere else or returning next year.

Gone:

  1. Bryneus - Oliver played just 448 minutes all season. Normally players that have that limited amount of time don't make the next year's roster.
  2. McRobb - the bulk of Finn's 519 minutes happened in a five-game stretch a third of the way into the season as he took his turn at trying to fill the left back role made available due to Stanley's season-ending injury. Once McAuley began to tweak the lineup and settled in on Quinn in that left winger role, McRobb's minutes dwindled to almost nothing. I would be surprised if he returns.
  3. Pruter - Late season loan; back to the Columbus Crew 2 mothership.
  4. Schaefer - Late season loan; back to Cincinnati 2
  5. Zalinsky - Late season loan; back to St. Louis CITY 2

Possibly Gone:

  1. Collier - The leader in the team's substitute appearances (by a wide margin) averaged just over 16 minutes per game in league play and didn't manage to score a goal all season. This was likely year two of a two-year contract and the limited minutes and lack of goals makes it difficult to imagine he returns for another year. At 30 years old, he may be looking for a team where he can find more minutes in what remains of a player's short career.
  2. Hogan - Pat averaged 65 minutes in league play and played in 19 games with 12 starts, but nearly all of those were early in the season. Hogan didn't make an appearance in the final 10 games of the season.
  3. Neidlinger - I guessed correctly that he would be part of the 2025 roster. However, the promise that he showed last year didn't translate to minutes this year, getting just 133 minutes in league play in 7 appearances off the bench. For a kid who accepted a contract to play professional soccer and gave up his college eligibility, he's going to want more minutes. Don't be surprised if you see his name on a League One roster next year trying to get those minutes.
  4. O'Brien, Josh - Was a versatile player that had a reasonable amount of minutes and games played. He wasn't a very expensive contract, so depending on how much that gets negotiated, my gut still tells me that O'Brien won't be around for 2026.
  5. Soumaoro - The arrival of Soumaoro last year pushed Lindley from the starting lineup. Soumaoro's injury this year, and the subsequent reshuffling of the lineup by McAuley, pushed Quinn into a winger role giving him more time to do what he does best which also allowed Lindley back onto the field showing his value. I can see Brem slide into the Returning camp, but for now, I think he doesn't return next year because I think Lindley does return and Lindley demonstrated his value.
  6. Sulte - This will, once again, depend highly on what Portland does with their goalkeeper situation. If they keep all the other guys, they might loan Sulte back to Indy yet again. If they saw enough out of him during his second year here, he might make his way to the Portland first team roster and he will have finished his time here in 2nd place in the team's shutout and saves lists behind Jon Busch.
  7. White - I know McAuley valued White in 2024, but his use this year was sporadic, even without taking into account his injury. He's another player that I could see slide into the Returning list, but for now I'm placing him in the Possibly Gone list.

Probably Returning:

  1. Blake - Unless other teams come calling with more money, which could be possible and likely, Blake is a "core" player to build around. 
  2. Charles-Cook - An outlier to the minimal minutes rule, I think Reice returns next season. He came here with a specific role in mind, that of a backup, but experienced, goalkeeper and he served that role well. He played reasonably well when called upon, including his 10 save game against the Philadelphia Union in the U.S. Open Cup, and he seemed to like his time here in Indiana. I think McAuley and the team keep him around.
  3. Lindley - All of what I said the past two year's applies: "A local guy who was a cornerstone of the roster this year. Cam wants to be in Indy closer to family. There aren't guarantees in the business of soccer, but Lindley returning next season might be close." In an episode of the Indy Eleven Coaches Show, McAuley said, "Two quick things I said to the players at the start of the season. Performance and attitude will keep you at the club. If one of them is not there, the one I'm choosing is attitude. If your performance is not there, but you've got a good attitude, you've got a good chance of staying. If your performance is there, and your attitude is not there, you're not staying. And if you've got both, then we've got a decent squad. Simple enough?" From my perspective, Lindley's attitude and talent are both there. I don't see how the team doesn't keep him around.
  4. Murphy - This season, the starting lineup became very predictable as injuries and performances dictated who would be on the field. For two years, you could basically put Murphy's name on the starting lineup in Sharpie. He finished the season having played in all 30 league games, all 5 Jagermeister Cup games, and 1 of 2 of the U.S. Open Cup games. His minutes did drop off a little at the end of the year, so I have to wonder if his fitness began to take a hit as the season drew to a close due to the minutes and miles he has put in over the past two years. Regardless, he'll be back. 
  5. Musa - Began to find a starter role in the tail end of the 2024 season and grabbed it with both hands in 2025. He played in one less game than Murphy, but played more minutes. The defense had a habit of leaking bad goals, but I still think he returns.
  6. Ofeimu - Indy conceded a lot of goals and at inopportune times, but I don't know how many I would consider to have been Ofeimu's fault. Just a guess, but I think he returns next season..
  7. Quinn - In the past two Soccer Saturday's with Rakestraw, Quinn was mentioned by McAuley or interviewed outright. In both instances it was said, while not "official" yet, Quinn will be back next year. It could be his last year here depending on how well his body holds up, but it might not be his last in Indy if there's a way to keep him around as he transitions to a coaching role.
  8. Rendon - The jump from League One to the Championship wasn't seamless and he had some moments where you could tell he was still adjusting. His pace and his ability to defend and go forward, make him a player that I think McAuley keeps around.
  9. Stanley - Other than Murphy, until his season-ending injury, Stanley was another you could put into the staring lineup with a Sharpie. Despite no data on which to evaluate him after the 8th game, I think Stanley will return.
I hear you. Where are the forwards? What do I think is going to happen with Amoh, Foster, Kizza, and Williams? I don't know which ones will be staying or leaving, but I would bet that only one or two of them return. I can make arguments for each of them, but I'm really not sure which one(s) McAuley values more than the others. My gut says it might be Foster and Williams even though Amoh was the second leading scorer in all competitions behind Blake. Foster's speed and desire to take on defenders sets him apart. Williams' hold-up play sets him apart. Who stays and who goes may have a lot to do with what players the team recruits to come to Indy.
  1. Amoh
  2. Foster
  3. Kizza
  4. Williams

Wednesday, November 6, 2024

Indy Eleven 2024 Season Recap & 2025 Off-Season Outlook

I started the recap of the 2023 season asking the question about whether simply making the playoffs was enough to consider a season successful. Last year, that answer was mostly "maybe." Indy hadn't been to the playoffs since 2019, so getting to the playoffs was a positive step. Getting bludgeoned 5-1 by Charleston in the opening round of the playoffs was clearly not a positive finish to the season, but the playoff appearance was an important step. 

As Coach McAuley stated after Sunday's defeat to Rhode Island, "In football, if you stay the same, you're probably getting worse. So we need to improve next year and improve again and just keep improving." When thinking about this season as compared to last season, it's easier to consider the 2024 season a successful one, despite finishing the season at the exact same stage as last year. Indy had an U.S. Open Cup run to the tournament's semifinal game. Indy finished top four in the Eastern Conference to be able to host the opening round game of the playoffs. Indy improved.

Yet, those same lingering frustrations remain that fans felt last season when the season was over. Indy finished the season feeling like they should have done better in their final game. Which, I think, is a fair complaint. It's easy to continually see the success across the Ohio River and want there to be more success on this side of the river. It takes a winning culture, and a lot more consistency than what Indy has ever had in its history. I'm going to discuss a lot of this later, but if you base the success of a season based only on the result of the team's last game, only one team would ever be able to say that they had a successful season. 

So much has happened this season that it's difficult to narrow down which part was the most impactful. In some ways, it felt like the transition between the 2017 and 2018 seasons when the team switched coaches, leagues, and playing venues. A lot happened this year.

  • In November of 2023, it looked like we were headed toward a third season with Mark Lowry, who had successfully returned the team to the playoffs with a core group of players who seemed to be returning for 2024 to continue to improve upon that step. By the end of the month, Lowry and the club decided to part ways. 

  • A couple of months later, the team hired Coach McAuley who came to Indy with limited first-team level coaching experience but who, like his predecessors, was confident that he could bring success to the club. I wondered before the announcement if it really even mattered who would be selected as the coach. Indy's periodic, but regular replacement of coaches has made my pessimism strong. More on Coach McAuley later. 

  • A few months after that, the Mayor of Indianapolis dropped a bombshell on the club and its supporters with a press conference where he announced that he had taken a trip to NYC to see Don Garber to discuss the possibility of bringing MLS to Indianapolis, while also announcing a new Professional Sports Development Area different from the Eleven Park site. Over the next couple of months, I had some thoughts on the entire debacle. More on the stadium later.

  • Starting in the last game of April all the way until mid-June, Indy did not lose a game. In a 9-game undefeated streak that started with a draw against Colorado, the team then proceeded to go on an 8-game league win streak with wins against North Carolina, Monterey Bay, Miami, Hartford, Phoenix, Pittsburgh, Birmingham, and San Antonio before losing at home to Orange County. Built around and within that undefeated league streak was also a historic run in the U.S. Open Cup, which put Indy on a 12-game undefeated streak, with 11 wins and USOC wins against Chicago Fire II, Detroit, and San Antonio. Even after Indy's league loss, the team beat Atlanta United in the USOC to get to one of the tournament's semifinal games against Sporting Kansas City.

  • Indy clinched a playoff spot in back-to-back years for the first time since the 2018-2019 seasons, which are the only two times that the team has been in the playoffs in consecutive seasons. Indy then clinched a home playoff game for the first time since 2019.
Everybody would have liked to see Indy progress further in the playoffs, particularly with the first game being hosted at Carroll Stadium, but it would be disingenuous to say that the season wasn't successful. Removing the loss in the playoff game and the stadium debacle, Indy took steps forward. Whether they can take more steps forward in 2025 will be seen.

To that end, here are my thoughts when looking towards next season.

Looking to 2025

Stadium

The stadium is in an absolute state of limbo, at least as far as the fans are concerned. I plan to have a dedicated article to the stadium in the coming days/weeks so I won't get into it much here. However, what we, as fans, know is very little. The Eleven Park site that included a groundbreaking in 2023 with the Mayor and Governor in attendance, and had the Diamond Chain buildings demolished from its site, appears to be frozen in time from where it was when Mayor Hogsett made his announcements about MLS and the process of converting the Eleven Park PSDA to a new location began. Whether that is a temporary stoppage or a permanent stoppage is dependent on how Mr. Ozdemir (and the rest of the ownership group?), Keystone, and Indy Eleven address the potential thousands of human remains that may be present in the burial ground that was Greenlawn Cemetery where Eleven Park was going to be constructed. Again, I plan to discuss more soon, with a much more detailed article, but the stadium design has been put on hold, construction has ceased, and the team would offer no real comment to me other than to say that, "Once we have a further update on the new stadium and Eleven Park, we will share accordingly." That could be this week, next week, next month, or 6-months from now. Only they know. What fans know is that Rhode Island, who entered the Championship this year, will begin playing in their new soccer-specific stadium next season, while Indy, in their 12th season, will continue to play at "American Soccer's Greatest Dive Bar." To add salt to the stadium wound, Fort Wayne FC announced this week that they will be building a new stadium and will begin playing there in the 2026 season. 

Coach
Coach McAuley was announced in early January and was quick to endear himself to the fans who were able to meet him at his first appearance with the fans in late January. My impression was that he was a nice person, with a desire to play a different style of soccer than his predecessors, and seemingly with the support of the players who had been announced by then. Coach McAuley continued to impress me throughout the season with his desire to do right by the fans. He even reached out to me personally when a mix-up in schedules meant that I was not afforded an interview that I was told could happen. I appreciate that personal touch.

I think he wants to be here. I think he wants to build something in Indy. I think he might be able to get it done. 

I thought all of those things about Mark Lowry who wanted to be here until he didn't. It took until after the second season for Lowry to realize that he didn't want to be here any longer. How long it takes for McAuley is unknown to me, but history of this team has proven that it might not be very long. Maybe McAuley will prove me wrong.

However, in comparison to other first year results of the Indy Eleven coaches, McAuley ranks second in percentage of points won across all competitions. Coach Hankinson's team in 2016 won or drew 81.1% of the time, while Coach McAuley's team this year won or drew 67.50% of the time. Coach Hankinson's value is inflated slightly because that counts the "friendly" win against Pachuca, but even without that value, he's still ahead. Only Martin Rennie's second season with the team in 2019 (72.50%) was more successful than McAuley's debut season. Those rankings remain the same if you look at the successes on a Points/Game basis. Given that the 2016 and the 2019 teams are the only times that Indy has ever had a significant positive goal differential, and this year's team was the only one of the Eastern Conference playoff teams with a negative league goal differential (the USOC run likely helped bring Indy's overall goal differential into a positive value thanks to three shutouts in the run), it's clear that McAuley's team this year were in a bunch of close results. McAuley came into the season stating that he wanted the team to score a lot of goals and would have the team play in a way to try and do that (pressing high in the opponent's half, getting the ball into the attacking third as quickly as possible, etc.). The 59 goals that the team scored this year were a club record setting total, but unfortunately, they conceded 56 goals. That's something that McAuley will want to get remedied next season.

I stated last year that Lowry getting the team back to the playoffs was enough for him to continue on in Indy unless a different team came calling offering a better opportunity or money. I think the same applies this year for McAuley. It would be difficult for Ozdemir and Stremlaw to fire a coach that lead his team to a Top 4 finish in the conference. Given McAuley's relatively thin first-team resume, I would be surprised if a lot of clubs are seeking him out right now. Another year of similar, or better, success and it might be a different conversation. So unless McAuley wants to leave (and my hunch at this point is that he wants to stay) or he gets a better offer, McAuley will be back next year to try and improve upon his inaugural season with the club.

Players

After the Rhode Island game, Coach indicated, "We gotta make decisions about players. I've already got a picture in my mind what it looks like so that's going to be easy for me to make them decisions."

Repeating myself from last year, "As I've discussed over the years in these season end reviews, it seems like the majority of the player contracts for Indy Eleven have the appearance of 2 year contracts or 1 year contracts with a 2nd year option. The existing contracts, loans, and trades that happened this year make it another year where it could be difficult to accurately determine who will be returning next year. However, all the roster movement also meant that Lowry McAuley brought in or released the players that he thought would make the team better. Moving forward will likely be this core, while also bringing in depth at all positions," which McAuley also said in his remarks after the Rhode Island game would be likely.

Based on my own opinions, here are what players from this year's roster that I can envision being somewhere else and who might be returning (I'm including all players that were on the roster, even the ones that were transferred away, for completeness, but am not including the Academy players as they seem to fall under an even larger variable than the 1st team players):


Gone:

  1. Barbir - He was signed when Lowry was the coach and last just three games before being transferred to Miami. 
  2. Boudadi - The frequently injured player was transferred to Hartford in June. He liked being in Hartford, and felt aggrieved by his release from Indy based on his X post at that time. 
  3. Henderlong - Played just 119 minutes on the season. Even when you're looking for depth, those players rarely return the following season.
  4. Ikoba - He was on a loan from Portland and they recalled him back in June where he dropped back down to their MLS NEXT Pro team for the remainder of the season. Maybe they try to loan him to Indy again, but I doubt it.
  5. Klein - Indy's first "Undrafted" signing. He was on the roster for less than a month. 
  6. Molina - He was a carryover from the 2023 season and played just 4 minutes this season before being part of the transfer deal to Miami.
  7. O'Brien, Ethan - Just 36 minutes all season, the bulk of which came in a 27-minute stretch against Las Vegas in the game before the USOC semifinal where McAuley was rotating players. Those players rarely return. However, my impression is that Ethan's contract was not substantial. So maybe he becomes one of the outliers to return despite his minimal minutes, but I doubt it.
  8. Sanchez - A single minute of action and was on the injured list for a lot of the season. Feels like the kind of player that doesn't get his contract renewed when the team is looking to build additional depth on the roster. Though he's also a young kid who was recently on an Academy contract so he could slide back into the roster and it wouldn't surprise me.
  9. Schneider - Minimal minutes and nothing since the middle of the season.

Possibly Gone:

  1. Gibson - It pains me to say it, but I think Gibson won't be returning next year. Top 10 in club history in Minutes Played, Games Played, and Games Started, but he was non-existent on the game day rosters at the end of the year. If he wants to stick around for depth, maybe he's here. At his age, I can see that happening, but I could also see him hanging up the boots if he's not interested in uprooting his family again.
  2. Guenzatti - Repeat everything I just said about Gibson except change it to Games Started, Goal Scorers, and Total Points. In a playoff game where Indy needed a goal, McAuley brought on Diz Pe while Guenzatti watched helplessly from the endline. I don't know if that says everything, but it might mean that Guenzatti has played his last game for Indy. I hope not, but I think the possibility exists.  
  3. King - Hampered by injuries all season, Macca played just 63 minutes this season. A carryover from last season, if he was on a 2-year deal, I don't know that he gets an extension. Will likely depend on whether McAuley saw enough from him in training for the team to offer a 1-year extension.
  4. Mines - Mines was a quick starter for McAuley when he arrived in Indy from Miami, but has dropped off substantially in recent weeks (though still getting playing time just not as frequent), particularly after the late-season additions. McAuley saw enough in Mines to bring him here, but it might be a single season here.
  5. Musa - Has provided depth at the back, and began to find a starter role in the tail end of the season. Musa’s return next year may be dependent on the contract amount. His mid-season arrival could have meant a short-term contract that would need to be renegotiated this off-season. That negotiation could bring him back or send him on the road.
  6. O'Brien, Josh - Was a good defender to have for depth. Like his brother, my impression is that his contract wasn't substantial. I'll put this comment here, but it could apply to most/all of the defenders on the roster. The team conceded 56 goals. If McAuley is looking to fix that problem, a few of the defenders that I list in Possible Gone or Probably Returning could easily switch to Gone.
  7. Oettl - Until his injury, Yannik was the clear #1 for Lowry last year. He started this year in that same #1 position, but Sulte relatively quickly edged him out. What happens with Oettl could depend on what happens with Sulte (see below). He was also probably on a 2-year deal, so he might be looking for another team where he can get starter minutes. Again, subject to what goes on with Sulte...
  8. Sulte - This will depend highly on what Portland does with their goalkeeper situation. If they keep all the other guys, they might loan Sulte back to Indy again. If they saw enough out of him during his stint here, he might supplant one of the current guys, in which he won't be back in Indy next year. 
  9. Wootton - Same thing as Sulte, but make it Chicago instead of Portland. They may renew the loan or he may be gone. Difficult to say.

Probably Returning:

  1. Blake - Unless other teams come calling with more more, which could be possible, an 8-time Team of the Week player doesn't get left off the roster then next season. 
  2. Chapman-Page - Callum was on a loan deal in 2023. I think McAuley liked his physicality this year, though his injury stints might give the team pause. I think he returns though.
  3. Collier - Collier was Top 5 in the league in goals per minutes played, and played in 35 of the team's 40 games, but only getting 4 starts. His unpredictability makes him an interesting and dangerous weapon off the bench late in games. McAuley keeps him around.
  4. Diz Pe - Diz did a better job this season of controlling his emotions, with the exception of the two-game stretch late in the season where he was shown red cards. Other than that blip, Diz was a mainstay on the game day lineup.  
  5. Foster - Pacey goal scorer who willingly attacks opposition defenders one-on-one; maybe to a fault at times. Will get another year to try and score more than the 1 goal he scored for Indy this year.
  6. Lindley - All of what I said last year applies: "A local guy who was a cornerstone of the roster this year. Cam wants to be in Indy closer to family and Lowry wants him in the Indy midfield. There aren't guarantees in the business of soccer, but Lindley returning next season might be close." The one caveat that makes me wonder is how much Cam dropped off the lineup at the end of the season. He has to be a great person to have for depth and he wants to be in Indy. That is likely enough for me to believe that McAuley wants to have a player who has in recent years received league first-team recognition.
  7. Martinez – He’s likely at the end of a 2-year contract, but showed an ability to score, while also being third on the team in assists behind Stanley and Blake, respectively. We’ve seen his ability to play at different positions, which is always valuable to a coach when it comes time for game day lineup selection and flexibility on who gets used for each game. It might be a one-year contract with an option for more, but Martinez found himself on the field a lot, which to me means that McAuley has faith in him. 
  8. Neidlinger - It didn’t benefit the team (or club) in many ways to sign the recent Academy player to a pro contract so late in the year, but the team felt it was important to reward him for his effort and progress. On the Academy contract, he could have still competed with the U20s in the upcoming Academy League Cup, plus they could have continued to have an additional substitute sitting on the bench thanks to the new rule this year to promote giving Academy players game experience. Signing in early October, I seriously doubt that they signed him to a 1- or 2-month contract, so I fully expect the local kid to be wearing the Indy Eleven crest next year.
  9. Ofeimu - Upon arriving from Miami, Ofeimu was a staple in the back line and showed that he could play different spots within that line. Ofeimu played in every game except the season finale. While I know McAuley has some questions about how to solidify the defense, I think it’s going to at least partially revolve around getting the appropriate players to play with Ofeimu.
  10. Quinn - The other player in USL Championship history to have at least 50 goals and 50 assists besides Asante, and Indy's second leading scorer this year behind Guenzatti, Aodhan was a key component of the Indy midfield. He has also started setting roots here with a young family and that will make him want to stick around. McAuley would be crazy to not keep him.
  11. Soumaoro - The arrival of Soumaoro nearly coincided with the absence of Lindley from the starting lineup. While I think Lindley still has a place on this team, the fact that Soumaoro started taking many of Lindley’s minutes indicates to me that Soumaoro was able to do things that McAuley wanted. His persistence in the starting lineup at the end of the season when other options remained available for selection gives me confidence that he’ll be returning next season.
  12. Stanley - Stanley quickly moved up the team’s all-time assist leaderboard, finishing the season with 9 across all competitions (7 league, 2 USOC) to put him tied with Zayed and Lindley. He had been on pace to threaten the top 2 spot held by Dylan Mares, but didn’t have an assist in the final 21 league games. What he did do, though, was play every minute of every game he was in except for the final 27 minutes of the playoff game, the final 15 minutes of the USOC game, and two full games in league action when being rested for squad rotation, or 94% of the minutes available for him to play. Players with those kinds of minutes almost always return the next season.
  13. White - Much like Soumaoro, when he arrived in town, he immediately began finding himself in the starting lineup. He brings a different skill level that McAuley appreciates. Would suspect that the contract was for the end of the year, with an option for next year, which I think will be taken.
  14. Williams, Augi - Leading goal scorer for the team in league play. Leading goal scorer for the team in USOC play. He’ll be back.
  15. Williams, Romario - Didn’t score many goals, but he has good hold-up play and was starting to really figure out the partnership with Augi and was getting better with Foster. He returns as well to continue those partnerships.

Final Thoughts

With so much happening this year for the men’s team, it will be difficult to match for next year. USOC runs for teams at the USL Championship level are historic and rare, so it’s difficult to think that Indy could repeat that feat, but McAuley has already expressed a desire to do “at least 1 better” next year. Watching the team seemingly struggle in league play as they progressed further into the USOC, being able to manage players differently might be something that will be on the coaching staff’s mind next year if a USOC run does begin to materialize.

I’m sure there will be some news about the stadium. What and when and by whom is an absolute mystery to everyone not named Ersal Ozdemir or Mayor Hogsett. See my article, likely next week, for more of my thoughts on the stadium.

With a year under his belt, and a Top 4 finish in the conference, McAuley’s expectations for next season are going to go up. If other fans are like me, you would like to match those expectations, but history of the club has made that a difficult proposition. We have grown to accept that the setbacks happen just as frequently as the breakthroughs. However, the team improved from year 1 to year 2 under Rennie, and then did the same thing under Lowry (after the requisite setbacks in year 3 and 4 under Rennie…).  So a more successful second season under McAuley isn’t out of the question. With the core 15 players that I have listed as Probably Returning, that's a good start.

Monday, January 8, 2024

The McAuley era has begun in Indy

I said most of what I wanted to say yesterday about the new coaching hire, even before I knew who the Indy Eleven were pegging to be the new person leading the team. Today, the club announced that Sean McAuley would be taking the reigns on the sideline for the men's first team for the 2024 season. While I hope that I'm wrong, my opinion yesterday wasn't swayed by today's announcement. McAuley has minimal experience as a first-team head coach/manager, with short stints as caretaker/interim manager at Sheffield Wednesday in 2006 and again in 2009, and at Minnesota United for a bit this past season. He was the head coach of Sheffield Wednesday's Academy coach for 6 years, so there's at least that. He was at Sheffield at the same time as inaugural season player Jermaine Johnson, who was with the Sheffield first-team from 2007-2014 before joining Indy midseason.

None of that is enough for me to know how he's going to coach since he's only ever been an assistant at first-team level teams. What's his style, on and off the pitch? 

He has been on staff with Caleb Porter at Portland from 2012 - 2017, then on James O'Connor's staff at Orlando City in 2018 - 2020, before moving to Adrian Heath's staff at Minnesota. So it's not like he hasn't been around a high-level atmosphere, but there are still a lot of unknowns for me. 

After the announcement, the club posted the following about McAuley's mentality.

"I don't buy into the "it's going to take two or three years to turn anything around." As soon as we start the first training session, we'll be working towards winning the championship. It's that simple." - Sean McAuley

I don't think there has been a coach that has come to this club that didn't think the exact same thing. For whatever you thought of them and their style of play, Martin Rennie and Mark Lowry weren't short on confidence on their own ability to coach. Yet, something seems to always happen with this club, and we fall right back to my concerns from yesterday. 

I want to be wrong. I also have concerns. Those don't have to be mutually exclusive thoughts. I'm going to support him as much as possible, but I'm curious to see what happens if things don't start out the way he hopes; from his perspective and from the club's perspective.

Now that he has his own team, let's see what kind of players he and the front office bring in to, hopefully, fill in around the existing 12 players on the roster, so that we can start to see what kind of tactics he is planning to start with this season.