Showing posts with label Eleven Park. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eleven Park. Show all posts

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Indy Eleven 2026 Season Recap & 2027 Outlook

I normally give myself a couple of weeks after Indy's departure from the season, but I felt like working on evaluating this season and looking forward to next so we're bumping this up a little earlier than normal. Let's start out with the good news from the 2026 season.

* crickets *

Anybody?

* crickets *

Oh wait, I have a few things.

  • McAuley surpassed 100 games, becoming the longest tenured (by games) coach in club history and providing some consistency to a position that has been an absolute turnstyle over the years. 
  • Blake overtook club legend Eamon Zayed as the top goal scorer in team history. 
  • Quinn became the league leader in assists. He also surpassed the 100 games played mark to give the current team 3 players and a coach in the Century Club at the same time. 
  • Lindley became the first Indy player to surpass the 10,000-minute mark for the team. 
  • Rendon scored 12 goals across all competitions (10 in league play to finish the regular season tied for 11th in the USL Championship). 
  • Hafferty was an absolutely stellar acquisition late in the season.

The bad news is much easier to find. For the second year in a row, Indy had a chance to squeak into the playoffs in the last game of the year after some results went their way. However, just like last year, Indy failed to do so, losing in Charleston 1-nil. Indy only had the ball 18% of time, only made 142 passes (62 of which were considered "long" - 44%), but managed 14 shots with 4 on target from that limited amount of time with the ball. Given Indy's available players (game day roster included just 4 field players, one of which was a 15-year Academy player), McAuley came out in a highly defensive-minded 5-4-1 lineup with the apparent plan to limit Charleston chances (which was moderately successful), steal some opportunities (check), and be there at the end to try and steal a win (check). All things considered, the final game was about as good as they could do, but it wasn't enough. 

As I mentioned after the Louisville game after Louisville won their midweek game to clinch a first round home playoff game, the frustration of being an Indy Eleven fan is that even in a down year for Louisville (which included an unprecedented 4-game losing streak), they still managed to find enough results and have enough results go their way that they still ended in 4th place with a guaranteed home game. Indy, conversely (at that point of the schedule) were 90-minutes away from being eliminated from the playoffs despite having a 6-point advantage ahead of Miami with 2 games in hand just 5 weeks prior. A spectacular run-of-form from Miami, a continued string of injuries for Indy, and 1 point from their final 6 games left Indy in desperation mode headed to Charleston. Indy's early lost points from winning positions (more on that in a minute), their four-game losing streak in the middle of the season, and the absolute abysmal results to finish the year (1 point from the final 7 games) meant that they ended the season about where I thought they would be preseason; hovering around the playoff line.

Going back through some of my preseason discussions with people, John Morrisey stated, "There are enough mediocre teams that the 8 seed is on the table, but I struggle to make the argument for anything higher than that." That, my friends, is why he's so well known. Dude called it based only on the roster and some insight I gave him about what I saw in preseason exhibition games. My response was "I share your pessimism. I don't see how this team makes the playoffs, particularly if any of the veteran midfielders have to miss time." Seems like I knew what I was talking about too. As the injuries to the veterans piled up, the results flatlined. 

The starting lineup for the last game against Charleston was, by far, the most egregious version of it, with 5 defenders (Rasheed, Barry, Herbert, Craig, & Kibunguchy), 2 who have been playing wing backs throughout the season (Quinn & Hafferty), and a defensive midfielder who has been converted from a defender (O'Brien), but Indy's roster and tactics all season seemed to be based a lot on not conceding as many goals this year as last. That part was successful (56 last, 47 this year), but, conversely, Indy also didn't score as many goals either (55 last, 44 this year), still finishing the season with a negative goal differential across all competitions. Indy played to grind out games by defending and counter attacking. Sometimes that worked, sometimes that almost worked, and other times they beat themselves.

Much like 2025, the 2026 season was riddled with missed opportunities. Indy lost a significant number of points from winning positions, including 5 league games where they conceded in the 85th minute or later. In hindsight, the two games against Miami are arguably the most disheartening because a better result in even one of those games sends Indy to the postseason (assuming I'm doing my math correctly). 

  • March 28 draw vs Hartford (88' - O'Brien Own Goal) - 2 points lost
  • April 4 draw vs Pittsburgh (90') - 2 points lost
  • April 19 draw vs Birmingham (89') - 2 points lost
  • May 16 USL Cup "draw" vs Fort Wayne (90'+1') - win in shootout
  • June 13 loss vs Pittsburgh (90'+2') - 1 point lost 
  • August 9 draw vs Hartford (74') - 2 points lost
  • October 3 draw vs Loudoun (90'+5' - Farr) - 2 points lost
  • October 10 loss vs Tampa Bay (85' & 90'+2' for good measure) - 2 points lost

In 2025, Indy finished the season in 9th place with 35 points and a 10W-5D-15L record in league play.

In 2026, Indy finished the season in 9th place with 34 points and a 9W-7D-14L record in league play. 

"Deja vu all over again."

Last year, Indy had a 5W-3D-10L record on the road across all competitions, but they did even worse this year with an astonishingly garbage 1W-5D-11L record across all competitions away from Carroll Stadium. Indy were reasonably effective at home, despite the terrible turf, but Indy couldn't buy a result on the road. Indy's lone victory on the road this year was a 1-nil win against Sporting JAX, the worst team in the league, thanks to a 90'+2' own goal. If you can't get any results on the road, you have to be absolutely perfect at home and Indy wasn't that. Whoever works on the scheduling next year for Indy really needs to pay attention to the homestretch of games. This year, Indy was on the road in 4 of their last 5 (0W-1D-4L); in 2025, they traveled in 6 of the last 9 (losing all 6).

Looking forward to 2027, unless something drastically changes (more on that later), then I don't see Indy being anything beyond what they have been recently. A middle to low end of the table team who might squeak into the playoffs and then lose their first playoff game on the road.

Here are my thoughts when looking towards next season.

Looking to 2027

Stadium

Until an actual plan from the team or Ersal gets announced for what they intend to do now that the Eleven Park site is mired under the history of being a former cemetery with an unknown amount of human remains still located on the site, Carroll Stadium can be expected to be the team's unfortunate home field. And until they announce it (probably in conjunction with an an IBJ article), nobody else is going to know the plan. Players and coaches have complained about Carroll Stadium's turf since the beginning, and a replacement project in 2022 did very little to quell those complaints. Fans have complained about the amenities. A large track surrounds the entire field, pushing fans further from the action and periodically catching a player by surprise as their cleats slide out from under them and they find themselves on their ass. As I said last year, "American Soccer's Greatest Dive Bar" is losing its charm. Despite what announced attendance may tell you, actual attendance from my perspective continues to drop. The midweek games look horrendous on camera.

I know I'm in a minority of the outspoken fans on this, but I know there's also a low-key agreement with me by some too. Until I hear a better plan from the team and the ownership group, I will continue to argue that expanding the "championship stadium" listed in the Grand Park Master Plan to be large enough to support an Indy Eleven USL Premier level team (and meeting U.S. Soccer's First Division requirements) is the right plan. It has the ability to consolidate the entirety of the Indy Eleven infrastructure into a single location since the team's training facilities are already located there, the Academy train there, and the USL W team train and play there. From rumors, the smaller stadium in the Master Plan allows for Indy to meet the requirements to have a women's team in the USL Super League, which was supposed to have already happened in 2025 until the Mayor Hogsett/MLS fiasco started and pulled the Eleven Park rug out from under the team. Make the stadium a bit bigger with the ability to expand further and condense everybody into the location where Ersal and Indy Eleven are already managing the facilities. I fully believe that whatever fans you lose from the Indy/southside areas will be more than made up by new north side fans and/or promotions with soccer tournaments that allow youth players to come to games. Can you imagine a weekend soccer tournament at Grand Park with an Indy Eleven game on Saturday night where hundreds/thousands of young soccer players and their families can attend the game with a reasonable add-on to the tournament cost? Indy Eleven attendance numbers might actually be accurate and the atmosphere might improve to the early days of the team.

I've spelled out why this makes sense to me (Eleven Park at Grand Park) and until somebody explicitly tells me a different, better plan, it's going to continue to be my opinion.

Yes, I know Mayor Hogsett and MLS are still a thing. I took their MLS team and stadium survey. I still don't believe Indy is their first choice. 


Coach
Don Thompson Photography
I've had enough conversations with Coach McAuley now to know that he wants to come back. I also suspect that despite the lack of playoff appearances, he is probably getting offers from other teams. Maybe not high level teams, but maybe he is. He and I haven't talked about that. 

What I said last year stays true this year. "I fully expect McAuley to be back next year, trying to overcome the limitations that are set on Indy Eleven coaches with players. I don't think McAuley did enough to warrant being fired," but a second season not making the playoffs does begin to start a fire under his seat.  

What I don't know is how next year will be any different. I'll get into the players next, but if you assume a majority of this year's players return, in part because of financial limitations, but also part of the reason I think McAuley wants to return is that the club needs some consistency. Sign players, develop those players, and get better. Unless you have the financial backing to go out and buy talent, you have to accept that the seasons are going to swing back and forth between maximizing your available talent to make a playoff appearance and succumbing to injuries and failing to make the playoffs because the overall depth isn't there to compete week in and week out with the top teams in the league. 

Given the operational constraints of the club (stadium, budgets, etc.), the fact that McAuley wants to be here to try and improve the club says a lot about Sean the man.

Sidenote discussion: If/when McAuley gets tired of being in Indy or he gets let go, I would be intrigued by a Eamon Zayed-led Indy Eleven. I know from talking to him over the years that he would like to be here and has tried a couple of times when Indy has been between coaches. Z has been a successful League One coach and it might be time for someone to take a chance on him as a Championship coach.

Players

After a second consecutive season where Indy just missed out on participating in the postseason, you might think that there will be, again, an overhaul of the roster. I keep harping on the budget, but with that constraint, the current budget-friendly contracts might get renewed. 

After last year, McAuley stated that he was going to bring in players for 2026 that were younger and hungrier. I think he did that, but what we also found out was that while this year's roster was younger and hungrier than last year's, the younger showed to not be experienced or talented enough. As a result, McAuley had to rely on the veterans more who all became injured late in the season because they had to play so many minutes.

Last month, I wrote about the possibility of Indy, either willingly or by relegation once the USL Premier league starts and pro/rel enters the American chat, drops down to League One. Indy only had moderate success against the League One sides they played this year, and I stated at one point that Indy might be a mid- to low-Championship side, but might be an upper- to mid-League One side. I've said a few times in recent months that Indy had the lowest budget in the league at $1.2M. I recently found out that one of the top spending teams in League One was Boise who spent...$1.2M. 

It's starting to feel like I know what I'm talking about.

As I mentioned in my "Could Indy Eleven's Inaugural Season Been Different?" article from a few years ago, Peter Wilt let me know that Indy's inaugural player budget was...$1.2M. I'm nearly positive that the salary has gone up over the years, but for whatever reason, it has come back down. Actually, I do have a bit of a theory.

At best, Indy's on-field performance has been spotty over the years and definitely not consistent top-of-the-league results. As the team continues to be stuck in mid-table seasons, more and more people have stopped buying tickets. Fewer people in stands means less ticket sales, less merch sales, and less concession sales. As a result, the club has to try and find the money in other ways, which is typically through sponsorships and ads. However, as fan attendance decreases, corporate sponsors see less value in providing the same amount of money to reach fewer people. As a result, they begin to decrease their dollars. With decreasing fan money and decreasing sponsor money, the club has no choice but to decrease their player budget. Decreased player budget means that the players brought in are "hungrier," "younger," or maybe "aging out veterans" that aren't able to get consistently good results. More fans stop coming to games, sponsors spend less, budget decreases. Rinse and repeat until 1) club fails entirely, 2) drops down a league (soon a possibility in the USL pyramid), or 3) somebody comes in Wrexham style and infuses a new about of capital. While the 3rd doesn't always guarantee success, the jolt of money does make it feel like the team is trying to do something and fans and sponsors might come back too. 

Feel like this could be Indy's scenario. Minus the infusion of capital, which doesn't seem like is going to come from Ersal, and despite additional owners being listed on the website, none of those other guys are ever mentioned as being significant financial providers for the team. If I'm honest, that leaves options 1 and 2 as viable possibilities.

Until that happens, Indy's going to probably be towards the bottom of the budget spenders in the league with somewhere in the mid- to low-table results. With all that as a backdrop, here are what I think happens to this year's roster in the off-season.

Gone:

  1. Okello - That's obvious. He was transferred to Lexington in the deal that brough Henry-Scott and Hafferty to Indy late in the season. McAuley thought highly of Okello, but I doubt it's enough to re-sign him.
  2. Neidlinger - One of Indy's Academy products, and Indy's youngest goal scorer in team history, but Logan's defensive deficiencies and Indy's desperation to get results forced the team to find somebody in his place. Neidlinger's time in Fort Wayne FC in League One seems like it might have been good for him. I suspect his was on a 2-year deal, which is ending this year and while I don't think Indy will re-sign him, I wouldn't be surprised if FWFC sign him for next season.
  3. Williams, K - he could never find minutes in McAuley's lineup (just 40 minutes in 4 league games, but he did find just under 400 minutes in the various Cup games) and eventually was loaned to Detroit FC. Those kinds of guys rarely make it back for another season, unless he had a guaranteed 2-year deal.
  4. Thomas - Played 107 minutes across 4 games. Unless he's on a guaranteed 2-year deal or is making the league minimum (which could be possible), I would suspect he's not around next season.
  5. Gavilanes - Only time he broke into the lineup was during the USOC games. Otherwise, he had a very noticeable 0 minutes played in 0 games. Like Neidlinger above, Gavilanes was loaned to a League One side with Union Omaha and seems to be having a good run there, including being named to the USL Prinx Tires Cup Team of the Tournament. Most of his time has been in USL League One (or Miami FC, which arguably was like a League One team those seasons), so that may just be his level. Won't be surprised if he signs with a team in League One, but I doubt he returns to Indy.
    Sidenote: that team has 5 players with Indy Eleven ties. Not sure what that means, but it is an interesting fact.

Possibly Gone:

  1. Craig - I'm not confident on this placement though. He was brought into the team, presumably for depth, but had to play a much more active role due to injuries to the other players. Craig battled his own injuries and just turned 34. Not saying he can't return, because he generally looked good most of the season, but he's also at that age when I could see him hang up the boots. This may hinge on whether he was on a 2-year deal.
  2. Hogan - No idea what to think here. I had Hogan in this exact same category last offseason because he was non-existent in the final third of the 2025 season. However, coming into this year, it was looking like he was going to be one of the starting center backs until his season-ending injury in preseason. If he was on a 2-year contract, it would be expiring. So I have no idea what may happen with Pat.
  3. Don Thompson Photography
    Rendon - Not because McAuley doesn't want him, but because I wouldn't be surprised if other teams with deeper pockets have expressed interest in having him. Even if he has contract remaining for Indy, for the right dollar amount, I could be gone. Where Indy's offense comes from if that happens will have to be sorted out with other signings this off-season.
  4. Kizza - Something just tells me he might not be back.
  5. Quinn - Dude's still playing at a high level, but he will be 35 years old when the season kicks off next year. He's already been doing some coaching with the Academy team. Is next year the year he transitions to the first team? If he's not ready to retire to the sideline, I would place him in the Probably Returning group because he's started setting down roots here in Indy and wants to be here. Don't think he pulls a Crash Davis-style end of his illustrious USL career to get one more season somewhere other than Indy. 
  6. *Hafferty and Henry-Scott - I had them in the Probably Returning category because I had mis-remembered the deal. I, correctly, remembered that Okello was a transfer to Lexington, but incorrectly remembered it being the same for Hafferty and Henry-Scott. As Anonymous indicated in the comments, section, they were actually loaned to Indy. So I'll put them back into the Possibly Gone category, but if money becomes available, don't be surprised if Hafferty is announced as a signing.

Probably Returning:

Literally everybody else. Due to the budget-friendly nature of this year's roster, there's limited risk to keeping everybody else, even if the team didn't make the playoffs. It will all come down to what pieces get added around them on whether this core of players repeats this year's meh season or can over-achieve. 
  1. Barry
  2. Blake
  3. Charles-Cook
  4. Dick
  5. Hafferty (see above)
  6. Henry-Scott (see above)
  7. Herbert
  8. Kibunguchy
  9. Lindley
  10. Mesanvi
  11. Mitrano
  12. O'Brien
  13. Omar
  14. Rasheed
  15. Sharp
  16. Sing
  17. White
Something that Coach McAuley has stated few times that has resonated with me is that, "In football, if you stay the same, you're probably getting worse. So we need to improve next year and improve again and just keep improving."

Looking at that potential returning roster, the obvious question that comes to mind is, "how does that team improve from a 9th place finish in the table with the majority of the roster remaining while potentially losing 4 of the more important pieces of it?" 

I really don't know.

But that's where we find ourselves as Indy fans. Stuck in a stadium that we already left once to go to Lucas Oil Stadium but boomeranged back into and then were told we would be in a fancy new Eleven Park stadium more than a year ago (that sucks to say after sitting in a tent in 2023 for the groundbreaking), all with the lowest player budget in USL Championship that is rivaled by at least one team in League One.

Monday, September 28, 2026

Indy Eleven to League One?

A couple weeks ago, Athletic Club Boise was announced as making the jump from USL League One up to the Championship for the 2027 season. With the announcement, Kartik Krishnaiyer from Beyond the 90', asked a very simple question, with a less than simple answer. "Why is a team paying an expansion fee to jump divisions when an open sporting ladder is supposedly right around the corner?"

Looking around the world, at teams that hover in the middle of their division for extended periods, I have to wonder if that plays into their thinking and Kartik's article suggests as much. Going down divisions can be simple. Getting back up can be much more of a challenge. By putting themselves into the Championship early, they get to see the level of competition before the promotion/relegation arrangement gets started. So when pro/rel makes its way to the USL pyramid, they're ready to compete, at a minimum, at the Championship level and not have to work their way up from League One. It does have other ramifications which Kartik discusses in detail, but where you start in the pyramid can go a long way to where you stay in the pyramid depending on how you spend.

Which gets me to the actual point of this article, which you've likely already guessed was going to be more Indy Eleven-centric based on the title. 

Indy Eleven have been a USL Championship team since 2018. For nine seasons, the Indy Eleven have been considered by many to be one of the premier organizations in the league, despite its less than consistent results and playoff appearances. Of the eight previous seasons in the league, Indy has made the playoffs half of the time, but have been bounced from the playoffs in the first round in three of the four seasons (2018 - Louisville 4-1; 2023 - Charleston 5-0; 2024 - Rhode Island 2-3), with the lone exception being the 2019 season where the team made the Eastern Conference Final. Indy's ability to make this year's playoffs could push them just above or just below .500 in their ability to play games beyond the league season.

And yet, this year's team feels like it's not fully prepared to be in the USL-C, despite its tenure and its current spot in the table. They currently sit in 7th place in the Eastern Conference, but with a roster and some results that give off League One vibes. In fact, this season, thanks to the U.S. Open Cup and the Prinx Tires USL Cup, Indy have played a League One team four times this year; Union Omaha twice, Fort Wayne, and Forward Madison. In those games, Indy lost to Union Omaha twice, drew Fort Wayne after conceding in 2nd half stoppage time, and beat Forward Madison for a 1W-1D-2L record. All three teams are currently in a playoff position, so maybe Indy is a fringe USL-C playoff team, but a solid League One playoff team? Indy's struggles this past weekend with Miami as some key components of the "first team" level players have continued to be beaten by the injury bug highlighted Indy's lack of elite depth at all positions.

As I've stated a few times this year, I've been told that Indy has the lowest salary in the league. "Per club policy, terms of the deal will not be disclosed" is Indy's standard language when it comes to player contracts, but the rumor is that Indy's total team salary is $1.2M (whereas I've heard that Loudoun is at $1.8M and Tampa is at $2.2M). There are a couple of things that interest me about that value:

  1. I have to assume that the midfield veteran triumvirate of Blake, Lindley, and Quinn, and Dick might all be making at least $100k each based on their league value (transfermarkt has them all higher than that number). Which means that the rest of the team is working at the league minimum. Rendon's transfermarkt value is also high, so I'm not sure how that's possible without the entirety of the rest of the team working second jobs (or housing benefits on top of the salary?), so the vets might be making less than my assumption.
  2. That value rings a bell for me, because Peter Wilt conveyed to me that Indy's inaugural season in 2014 was (drumroll...) $1.2M. I'm positive that the amount has increased in the 13 seasons, but if the rumors are correct, the number has again dropped back down to inaugural season levels. Based only on inflation numbers, Indy's $1.2M salary in 2014 would need to be at $1.8M today to get the same spending value. Yet we all know that USL-C now is a much better, and more expensive, league than NASL then, so Indy's current 7th place in the table is really kind of impressive. Currently punching above their weight based on salary, but Indy should probably be spending closer to $2M to have an overall roster that can legitimately compete with the top teams in the League. Easy to say when it's not my money. 

So the question that comes to my mind is "why"? Why is Indy spending so much less now than they were likely spending just a few seasons ago? Why hasn't there been any kind of stadium update from the team in over two years? Why did Indy lose very good parts of their front office staff last year en masse? 

Why does it feel like Indy is operating at a League One level?

It doesn't seem like Ersal's personality to willingly drop down a level to League One, but he's also not seemingly making many outward steps to stay within USL-C or prepare for a potential step up to the future USL Premier, which will require Division 1 standards. Detroit and Pittsburgh have plans in place to get their stadiums to Premier level, Louisville City's stadium already meets the capacity requirement, and North Carolina is on hiatus this year to prep for Premier. So teams are already preparing for the Premier league launch two years from now in 2028. However, Indy's Eleven Park seems fitting that it was intended to be located on a former cemetery because all outward indications are that the project is dead, with no announced plans in two years. After the groundbreaking in 2023, the demolition of the Diamond Chain buildings took place, but everything ground to a halt in 2024. Carroll Stadium, as currently arranged, can seat 10,000 to 12,000 depending on the utilization of the grandstands and the layout of "temporary" stands. Carroll could probably be further expanded with temporary stands to get to 15,000 (the Division 1 requirement), but that would continue to feel like lipstick on a pig. 

So if Ersal and Indy Eleven seemingly aren't preparing for USL Premier, and have continued to decrease salaries within USL-C to the point where Coach McAuley and the current roster are overachieving based on their respective league-wide salary, is Ersal planning to be in League One without making the mirror action of Boise? The team hasn't actively announced a plan to go to League One, but is that the plan? Obviously, nobody in the club has said anything even close to this to me. This is just a "what if?" exercise for me. An exercise that I can't immediately decide isn't a possibility.

The recent round of MLS to Indy discussion actually helps Ersal in this regard. It gives him an excuse if/when the club drops levels or, potentially, fails altogether and shutters. Ersal can claim (maybe rightfully) that Mayor Hogsett's 2024 actions made it difficult to attract the highest level players and, just as importantly, significant level sponsors when nobody knows if the team will be around. While some cities can support multiple professional soccer teams, it's doubtful that Indianapolis is one of them. So Ersal has an "out" when he decides to stop losing money on this venture and closes shop. "The Mayor began the downward spiral" might not be 100% accurate, but there is a definite point in the history of Indy Eleven, from April 2024 when the mayor announced his plans to pull the funding of Eleven Park from Ersal and work towards an MLS team, that things haven't seemed "right" with the club. 

"Conflict arises when expectations exceed reality." When I wrote that last August, my closing statement of the article was:

The expectation is that Indy will be competing for Championships in a world class facility. The reality is that Indy has been a club with middling results and above average announced attendance, but is struggling to come to grips with the fact that all outward signs point to Indy playing forever in Carroll Stadium or failing and ceasing to be.

In the subsequent 13 months, I have now begun to wonder if there isn't another caveat on the table, which is a drop in leagues to League One. This would allow Ersal to continue to have a professional soccer team on his resume, but at a much lower financial burden. A financial burden he's probably closer to spending anyway based on this year's salary. Every so often though, the team could overperform and get promoted back up to the Championship, but in either case, Carroll Stadium is still an "acceptable" stadium. 

Unless, of course, my other idea for financial stability that includes moving the team to Grand Park comes to fruition. Though, actually both ideas could come into play since the Grand Park Master Plan includes a 10,000 seat stadium, which would work for either a Championship or League One level team.

I know many fans hated my idea of a Grand Park-based Indy Eleven, but what would be your thoughts of a League One-based Indy? Are the remaining fans really "XI 'til I die" no matter the league or level, or would that be the final straw? Would an Indy Eleven team that bounced between the Championship and League One because that's the salary level that Ersal was willing to spend be acceptable?

My guess is that Ersal has always had First Division aspirations, but at some point, time and money and a rug-pulling mayor may have become too much for him to handle. Time may tell us whether a League One Indy Eleven is the goal or just the result.

Thursday, April 30, 2026

The Capital Improvements Board's MLS Indy team & stadium survey

I don't know how many people have received the email from Lucas Oil Stadium and the Capital Improvements Board of Managers (CIB) last month requesting participation in a survey to "understand market support for an MLS expansion team playing in a new soccer-specific stadium in Indianapolis," but I wanted to walk through some of the survey and my responses. I tried to get screen captures of each question as I went, but I think I missed some of the pages. 

It's difficult to tell where anybody actually stands on this because so much of the information that I've heard or that has been published by other sources continues to feel like pissing matches between the Mayor's camp and Ersal's camp. Even with the recent discussion about the Vancouver Whitecaps potentially having their franchise relocated (not an unprecedented thing in MLS), to a different city thereby not taking of the presumed future new franchise spots, I still haven't seem any articles that include Indianapolis as one of the prime and viable options (though there were some rumors that seem to be a stretch for me to believe). As a result, it's difficult to ascertain the end goal of the CIB's MLS stadium survey. Legitimate inquiry into the interest and viability of a MLS team in Indianapolis, or political theater? 

If it's theater, I've been an actor in this play for the past dozen years, so I might as well do what I do, which is talk about my experiences with professional soccer in Indianapolis.

From the email requesting participation in the survey:

The CIB is conducting a survey aimed at understanding thoughts and opinions on a variety of topics including:

  • Current Indianapolis Sports Engagement & Attitude towards MLS in Indianapolis
  • Stadium Amenities & Game Day Atmosphere
  • Seating Opportunities
  • Food and Beverage Preferences
  • Intended Engagement with MLS in Indianapolis

After clicking the link to get to the survey, the opening Introduction page includes a series of photos of what is expected to be similar stadiums from around MLS and reiterated the intent of the survey. An interesting aspect to the survey that immediately came to mind was that the colors that the CIB chose to utilize for the survey are either exactly like, or at a minimum very similar, to those of the Indiana Pacers, owned by the Simons. Does that mean anything? Maybe not. Still an interesting color selection from my perspective.



The very first question (and my answer) asked was "How would you characterize your attitude toward an expansion MLS team being awarded to Indianapolis?
  • Very Positive
  • Somewhat Positive
  • Neutral
  • Somewhat Negative
  • Very Negative
"Why do you feel this way?"
I appreciate the potential for a 1st division soccer league team, but feel that the presence of Indianapolis' current professional team, Indy Eleven, should be considered and incorporated into any team that moves forward. The fans of that team should not be alienated with a new team, and I feel it is undesirable for that team to fold if a MLS team were to materialize.

"How would you characterize your attitude toward the development of a new soccer-specific MLS stadium in Indianapolis?

  • Very Positive
  • Somewhat Positive
  • Neutral
  • Somewhat Negative
  • Very Negative

It's no surprise that I think a soccer-specific stadium would be a good thing. I've literally said it on this site for more than a decade. 

"Why do you feel this way?"

A soccer specific stadium allows for a fan experience catered to soccer fans, while also allowing for scheduling flexibility and potential for other types of soccer events to take place (NCAA tournament games, national team games, etc.)

Other notable questions within the survey are the following:

 "Why are you interested in purchasing season tickets?"

  • Fan of Soccer in General
  • Fan of Indianapolis Sports
  • Fan of Sports in General
  • Opportunity to Entertain Friends/Family
  • Opportunity to Entertain Clients/Employees/Other Business Uses
  • Convenient Stadium Location
  • Other, Please Specify
"Ignoring price, what the the most important factors to you when considering the purchase of season tickets at a new Indianapolis MLS stadium? Please select up to 10 factors."
  • Proximity to the Pitch
  • Proximity to the Centerline
  • Co-Location with Friends/Family
  • Ease of Access to Seat
  • Seat Comfort
  • Ease of Access to Key Stadium Locations (i.e. Entrance/Exits, Bars, Restrooms, Concessions)
  • Access to Private Club Lounge / Membership Club
  • Seats in the Sun
  • Seats in the Shade
  • Covered Seating
  • Pre-Match Activities (Fan Plazas, Party Areas)
  • Ability to Purchase Parking / Parking Included
  • Private Stadium Entrances
  • Enhanced Benefits (Invitations to Private VIP Events, Concierge Service)
  • Access to Third-Party Events
  • Access to Enhanced Food & Beverage Offerings
  • Access to All-Inclusive Food & Beverage Offerings
  • Seats on the Home Side of the Stadium
  • Seats on the Visitors Side of the Stadium
  • Other, Please Specify
After a few follow-up questions about those factors, including ranking my personal preference for the items that I selected, the survey moved into the Seating Opportunities section. The first section described each of the seating choices, as well as where those choses would reside within the stadium. After the sections were described, the survey then asked, "if these were your only options, which would you chose?" A page of 5 options were then presented with a section of the seating highlighted, what the section was designated (reserved, club, general, etc.), and the potential price. This went on for 10 pages, giving a total of 50 price options. However, as I went through the sections, it felt like there were sections that were highlighted more than once. After looking back through my screenshots of the options, that turned out to be true, with the Section 7 seats having 6 different price points, drastically different from each other and with different designations (reserved versus club). I assume that's to gauge how much people are willing to pay for certain sections of the stadium, but specifically for that section which had the most alternatives and widest range, the cost ranged from $660 reserved seats to $3,475 club seats. Within all of the 50 prices points, the minimum season ticket price was $510 for a reserved seat and the maximum was a $5,100 club seat. The average of all the price points listed, regardless of type of seat was $1,850. Limiting the evaluation to just the sections that were described as Reserved, the average season ticket cost was $1,177. 

By contrast, the most expensive season ticket for Indy Eleven for the 2026 season was $1,062. Admittedly, the new soccer-specific stadium would have much better seating, concessions not run out of cargo containers or food trucks, and significantly more restroom facilities, while also having actual locker rooms for the players, media facilities, no track, etc., and be associated with 1st Division soccer in this country, but that's a significant jump in price point for most current Indy Eleven fans, i.e. the people who are currently supporting professional soccer in Indianapolis.



The following summarizes each of the seating options, and the survey's descriptions and locations for each type of seat.

"A potential MLS stadium in Indianapolis could feature a variety of seating options designed to accommodate all types of fans, including:

  • Reserved Seating
    • Reserved Seating locations could include standard-sized stadium seats with access to general concessions, restrooms, and public entrances. 
    • The purchase of a Reserved Seat would include tickets to all Indianapolis MLS preseason and regular home games played at the stadium each year. Additionally, it would provide priority access to purchase tickets to playoff games and other select stadium events.
    • Location
      • Lower Level East Centerline
      • Lower Level East Sideline
      • Lower Level Corners
      • Lower Level 18-Yard Box
      • Lower Level Endline
      • Upper Level East Centerline
      • Upper Level East Sideline
      • Upper Level East 18-Yard Box
      • Upper Level Corners
      • Upper Level Endline
  • Premium General Admission Seating
    • Premium General Admission Seating could offer an elevated experience from reserved seating. These seats could be configured as wider, padded stadium seats, or as ledge seats with a drink rail in front. Premium General Admissions Seats could also provide access to a private concourse with enhanced food & beverage options. 
    • The purchase of a Premium General Admission Seat would include tickets to all Indianapolis MLS preseason and regular home games played at the stadium each year. Additionally, it would provide priority access to purchase tickets to playoff games and other select stadium events.
    • Location
      • Lower Level East Centerline
      • Lower Level East Sideline
      • Lower Level North Endline

  • Club Seating
    • Club Seating could feature wider, padded seats with access to a private, climate-controlled lounge offering upscale food and beverage options. Additional benefits may include private restrooms, exclusive stadium entrances, and preferred parking access. 
    • The purchase of a Club Seat would include tickets to all Indianapolis MLS preseason and regular home games played at the stadium each year. Additionally, it would provide priority access to purchase tickets to playoff games and most other stadium events.

  • Small Group Seating
    • Small Group Seating could be designed to accommodate 4 guests in a semi-private environment, making it ideal for families, friends, or small businesses. Small Group Seating may include in-box wait service and access to upscale food and beverage options within a private club lounge located near the seating area. 
    • The purchase of a Small Group Seating would include tickets to all Indianapolis MLS preseason and regular home games played at the stadium each year. Additionally, it would provide priority access to purchase tickets to playoff games and other stadium events.

  • Luxury Suites
    • Luxury Suites could offer a private, premium experience for groups of 8 or more guests. Amenities may include a private lounge area with televisions, high-end decor, and a fully appointed service area featuring a buffet counter, refrigerator, and wet bar. 
    • The purchase of a Luxury Suite would include tickets to all Indianapolis MLS preseason and regular home games played at the stadium each year. Additionally, it would provide priority access to purchase tickets to playoff games and most other stadium events.



Thursday, February 26, 2026

Still Beckoning

It may not be overly apparent from this article title, but I have continued to struggle with whether I want to continue this site. Year after year I take the Indy Eleven offseason to evaluate whether I want to spend another season devoting my time to writing about my hometown team. Around the final third of each season, the frustrations and time commitment that I spend trying to write the best articles that I can start to feel like it's not worth my time. After spending the summer months writing about the men's team and the women's team, the sheer quantity of games and articles starts to wear on me since this originated as a hobby and is not my full-time job. As I indicated in my unfiltered thoughts after the men's team's USL Cup quarterfinal loss to Greenville, there was a stretch this past June during the W League season where I attended 4 games and wrote 6 articles in a 9 day span (Friday to following Saturday). Even with a hobby that you enjoy, that was a lot to write.

After the off-season consideration of whether to walk away from the keyboard, I'm planning to be back for another year of covering Indy Eleven, and have submitted my request for season-long credentials (which I know as of the time of this article that I and my photographers have been approved to receive). Another year of articles, discussions with the coaches post game, and stadium/MLS talk. Maybe even a few articles this year on some of the World Cup games.

With one major caveat...

I'm going to write when and how much I want. When you request season credentials from Indy Eleven, it states that if you don't intend to cover at least half of the home games, then you should request credentials on a game-by-game basis. Women's team games requires a separate credential request, but generally indicates the same thing. So, at a minimum, the men's team credential request asks that you cover 9 games of the 18-game home schedule. With the women, if I were to request those credentials, that would be 2.5 games of the 5-game home schedule. By the team's requirements, I need to cover a dozen games over the two seasons. 

I plan to do more than that minimum, but maybe I don't get as detailed in my articles for the away games. Maybe I limit the away games to just the key details and not go in as much depth as I have in the past. Maybe I barely cover the women's away games. Racing Louisville barely covers the games so why should I struggle through a terrible feed to cover the game too?

Other than that's the standard I've set for myself and this site. That doesn't mean that I have to continue to overwhelm myself doing a hobby.

I've decided that I might, emphasis on might, bring a bit more levity and open honesty about the teams and the club. I've tried to be as professional of a writer as possible on this site, but I'm not a professional. I have no formal or informal training in journalism. It should be okay for me to periodically sound unprofessional.

So while some level of frustration has been and will likely remain a part of my ongoing relationship with this club and this site, I plan to continue to write this year, just maybe not at the depth or frequency as I have in the past. I want to also enjoy watching a game for the joy of watching a game and not evaluating it for things to write about.

Ken Block, the rally driver and of gymkhana fame, once replied when asked during an interview about his legacy, "I try to inspire people to be creative and live a fun life. And don't be an asshole."

This site has been my idea of being creative, I don't think I'm an asshole. Backing down the effort on this site this year will be my attempt to live a fun life. We'll see how it goes.

Monday, November 17, 2025

Eleven Park at Grand Park

In May 2023, Indy Eleven had an official groundbreaking ceremony on the Eleven Park site, formerly the Diamond Chain factory, with a stated goal of having the stadium open in time for the women's USL Super League team to start their inaugural season in the league in August 2025. At the time, I thought it was optimistic for them to meet that goal given that I knew from colleagues in my business that the stadium was still under design. I had no idea that nearly 900 days later, there wouldn't be a stadium and because there was no stadium, there wouldn't be a USL Super League team. Since my article in June 2023 talking about the groundbreaking, I've written 7 other articles talking either about the stadium, or more specifically, the lack of a stadium. Admittedly, one of those was poking fun at the easter egg items in the renderings for the stadium, but all the others discussed the lack of progress on the stadium that hasn't occurred after the Mayor of Indianapolis railroaded the team's plan for the Professional Sports Development Area and took it over for himself as he attempts to get a MLS team to Indy including one article last year around this exact same time discussing the Henry Street Bridge plan versus Indy's lack of plan. To date, that has been an unsuccessful task for the Mayor, but the Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission did recently vote to allow the City to purchase the downtown heliport, long suspected to be the preferred City location for an MLS stadium, and there have been other steps to prepare for a team that likely may never come, such as the Capital Improvement Board issuing a Request for Proposal in July related to the construction of the proposed stadium.

Since my article last year, there hasn't been a single announcement from Indy Eleven about their plan for Eleven Park, if there even is a plan for Eleven Park. In the sarcastic words of Roz, "you're stunned silence is very reassuring." 

So if there isn't a plan for the land at the Diamond Chain/Greenlawn Cemetery site, and all indications (none) would imply that that there isn't a plan for the site, but if we assume that a plan does exist for the team to continue working towards having its own stadium, then where will it be located? Arguments could be made for the Sand Street location and I have even taken a fresh look at what could be done at the Carroll Stadium site. Carroll Stadium is obviously still owned by Indiana University so that doesn't make it an ideal location if you're trying to control the scheduling, financing, and the income of the stadium. When Indy Eleven needed a place to start their life as a new club, Carroll Stadium was a good choice, and I wrote a tribute to the stadium in 2018 when the club transitioned from the NASL to the USL and from Carroll Stadium to Lucas Oil Stadium. Back then though, the 2012 IUPUI Master Plan had the grandstand of the stadium being removed:

"To create visual connectivity to the riverfront park, it is recommended that the Michael A. Carroll Stadium grand stands be removed. The track will remain and be improved as part of the active recreational portion of the park."

Indy Eleven saved the grand stand of Carroll Stadium. They made it better. The team transitioned to a much "better" stadium for a bit when they played in Lucas Oil Stadium, but then returned to the spiritual home of the team. The spiritual home of the team, though, is starting to feel like a final resting place instead of a home, and the long-time fans want to see the stadium promise come true.  

At one point, it might have been logistically possible for Ersal and the team to purchase the stadium from IU, but that no longer seems to be a potential. There was a follow-up study to the 2012 Master Plan and then a 2020 update to the Master Plan that viewed the stadium in a different light. Admittedly, the update occurred during the period when Indy was playing in Lucas Oil Stadium, so now that Indy is back in Carroll, there might be yet another update to the Master Plan in the works. However, the language from the 2020 Master Plan updated indicated (emphasis mine):

"A follow-up 2019 study identified the needs of the campus, as well as the needs of the Indianapolis amateur sports community which are lacking on campus and in the community. A flexible, multi-sport fieldhouse which could accommodate competition basketball, hockey, and gymnastics, as well as other sports was proposed south of the Herron School of Art and Design. [editor: this is currently in construction] The location reinforces the Sports District along the White River and offers great community access. 

The 2019 study also identified the need to improve Carroll Stadium with amenities, support spaces, and improved service. The study also identified the opportunity to develop an improved image and access to the stadium from the White River Trail which could flip the “front door” of the stadium towards the river and the trail. A new event plaza is proposed which can be used before events at the stadium and used as a space for the community who are using the trail."

While improved amenities, support spaces, and service would all be welcome additions for fans who have been using the facility the past 12 Indy Eleven seasons, this doesn't get Ersal and the team any closer to having their own stadium where they have more control over it. As I look at it though, a yet again reimagined look to the stadium could fit well in the existing space, particularly if you think about something that I mentioned a few years ago talking about my journey into watching the Scottish Professional Soccer League.

Tynecastle Park - Google Earth 3D Rendering
Tynecastle Park. 

For those that don't know, Tynecastle Park is the stadium where the Heart of Midlothian play their home games.

Let me back up one more step. Heart of Midlothian is a club that plays in the top level of the Scottish Professional League and are currently sitting at the top of the table above even Rangers or Celtic. 

Okay, back to Tynecastle Park. When I asked Nicky Law and Nick Ross about some of their favorite Scottish stadiums, they both, independently from each other, listed Tynecastle as one of their favorites. Sean McAuley spent 1992 - 1995 in St. Johnstone in the SPFL and he told me that Tynecastle was one of his favorites too ("Good history and I always played well there!!!"). Tynecastle has a capacity of approximately 20,000, with a length of 98 m (107.2 yd) and a width of 68 m (74.4 yd). Check out these couple of videos (the 2nd one is a lot of talking, so depending on your level of focus, you might want to skim through it).

Rough Sketch of Tynecastle at Carroll Stadium Location
https://youtu.be/O1-Zh-o1YKE?si=DOjgRknWLJsIUa29
https://youtu.be/bnyNuvvfPFY?si=A700kcdE_O0BaYNS

Why am I talking about Tynecastle Park so much? Because I think it would fit nicely in the space of what is available at Carroll Stadium. The boxy nature, and some of the other Scottish football stadiums for that matter, make that style of stadium a good fit in a location like Carroll Stadium, because there isn't a lot of extra building extending out where not necessary. I would love to see this kind of stadium for Indy Eleven, but then I've already said that before in my journey into the SFPL article.

Which is all leading up to my current thought for an Indy Eleven stadium. You saw the name of the article, so I'm sure you saw where this was going.

Grand Park. 

Or more specifically now, Droplight Grand Park Sports Campus, as it was announced this past week that Grand Park Sports & Entertainment had entered into a naming rights partnership with Droplight. Whatever you want to call it, I've come around to the idea that it's the right place for Indy Eleven to call home moving forward. 

Earlier this year, Grand Park released a Master Plan that included a massive expansion of the facilities. An expansion around the campus that includes parking garages, housing, offices, a park with a ferris wheel, an indoor ice arena, and most notably as it relates to this article, a 10,000-seat multi-purpose stadium. 

A 10,000-seat multi-purpose stadium that would be located at the intersection of 186th Street and Grand Park Boulevard, that would be "visible from the eastern approach along E 186th Street, [that] announces your arrival at the Grand Park District." Just north of the stadium, Ed Carpenter Racing has already agreed to build a new "76,000-square-foot state-of-the-art facility for all racing operations, engineering, and technical development." Part of that project also includes a new City-funded parking garage to replace the parking lots that are intended to go away with the Master Plan expansion plans. As a sidenote, I do wonder what that will do for the frequent RVs that are parked in the lots that families use when they are participating in events at the facility. 

My suggestion is to forego the 10,000-seat stadium, but rather build a 15,000-seat stadium to serve as Indy Eleven's new permanent home that would allow them to meet the standards to be part of the USL First Division league when it officially starts in 2028. First Division clubs in the United States are required to have 15,000 seats to qualify for First Division status. 

Many people will say, and have said when I floated this idea on X, that if Indy made that move, they would no longer go to games. I'm sorry, but this now makes the most sense to me. Whatever kind of relationship Ersal thought that he had with the previous and current Mayors of Indianapolis was flipped on its head when the current Mayor, Mayor Hogsett, took over the PSDA that was created specifically with Indy Eleven in mind. The current pissing match of egos likely means neither wants to back down, but it could be at the detriment of Indy Eleven if Ersal doesn't reconsider the path that he and the team have been taking since the days when Peter Wilt suggested a stadium before the team had ever played a single game. It has always been stated that the stadium was going to be in Indianapolis. That can be the path until it isn't.

Would Peter Wilt, the man who had learned from his Chicago days that a stadium in the suburb could be problematic and engrained that lesson into Ersal, agree with me? I didn't ask him, but this isn't Peter's team any longer. This club feels like it's floundering to find its footing of who it wants to be, and maybe that means moving to Westfield and Grand Park to reestablish themselves.

Why does this make sense to me?

"The City of Westfield is pleased to announce a transformative long-term collaboration with multiple partners, including Indianapolis-based Keystone Group, Indy Sports & Entertainment, Indy Eleven, and Bullpen Ventures, solidifying a landmark public-private partnership. 

... 

Grand Park and Indy Eleven have long-established relationships, with the multipurpose sports campus serving as the Indy Eleven’s Official Training Center. Indy Sports & Entertainment intends to build a new world-class training facility at Grand Park that will become the official training home of the Indy Eleven and the new women’s professional team that will play in the Super League.

... 

The City of Westfield will retain ownership of Grand Park, with the terms of the partnership outlining Grand Park Sports & Entertainment’s commitment to the development and management of the campus for up to forty years, valued at 300 million dollars to the City of Westfield.

This collaboration symbolizes a strategic convergence between public and private entities, poised to propel Grand Park into a new era of excellence, growth, and community engagement."

The only thing that has been in Indianapolis for Indy Eleven is 1) their official HQ where the majority of the front office staff resides, 2) the men's first team playing at Carroll Stadium, 3) an empty Diamond Chain lot that will likely be too cost prohibitive to ever build what they wanted to build in Eleven Park, and 4) a Mayor who no longer cares about the potential $1B in investment that was going to go into the Eleven Park campus. The remainder of the Indy Eleven enterprise happens within Grand Park, including now having the owner's other company collaborating on the development and management of the campus. Everything that they had envisioned doing with Eleven Park is incorporated into the Grand Park Master Plan.

To me, the question isn't why should Indy move to Westfield and Grand Park, the question is why shouldn't they? Putting the stadium at Grand Park consolidates everybody into a single location from men's first team to women's team(s), to the Academy, and training facilities. If you want to go to an Indy Eleven game, regardless of who is playing, you go to one place.

Will they lose some of the fans from south side of Indianapolis? Probably. Could they pick up more fans from north of Indy? Probably.

The counties of Hamilton (where Grand Park is located) and Boone and Madison (the two adjacent counties) account for a 2020 census population of approximately 550,000 people. The similarly located counties south of Indianapolis and Marion County (Morgan, Johnson, and Shelby) account for approximately 279,000 people. Just in a sheer numbers game, catering to the northern fans makes sense. When I asked the Indy front office if they would share with me heat map numbers of season ticket holders based on zip codes, I was, not surprisingly, told they wouldn't share that information with me. They did say, however, "I can at least provide top-line feedback that we do draw very well from North of the City especially and that base is continuing to grow."

Placing a stadium in that base is only going to help.

The excavation for the Henry Street bridge project recently completed its "Archaeologist-led excavation, rather than Contractor-led excavation" and uncovered more than 1,700 grave shafts. ("Grave Shaft: A burial area consisting of a rectangular pit with vertical sides; also known as a grave, a grave shaft can contain one, multiple, or no human remains within it."). The excavation also unearthed some of the concrete supports for the Federal League Park baseball stadium from 1914 (yes, the site was also used for a baseball stadium more than a century ago), so it seems realistic that the Eleven Park site could also be littered with building supports in addition to the unknown quantity of human remains that are likely more extensive than previously suspected since the Henry Street project had almost 3 times the amount that was originally anticipated to be expected. The cost to excavate the approximately 18-acre site to find every human remain would be astronomical and beyond what Ersal and Indy Eleven are capable or willing to do. 

There's an obvious level of irony that it's a cemetery that has caused the death of a development project, but it doesn't have to be the death of the stadium. The human remains from Greenlawn have been reinterred over the years and there's no reason that the remains of Eleven Park can't be relocated somewhere else too.

To me, the logical new location is Grand Park. I would like it to look like some version of Tynecastle Park. I think that version of a stadium would work nicely at Grand Park.



Tuesday, November 11, 2025

Indy Eleven 2025 Season Recap & 2026 Off-Season Outlook

I concluded the 2024 season recap with the following statement:

With a year under his belt, and a Top 4 finish in the conference, McAuley’s expectations for next season are going to go up. If other fans are like me, you would like to match those expectations, but history of the club has made that a difficult proposition. We have grown to accept that the setbacks happen just as frequently as the breakthroughs. However, the team improved from year 1 to year 2 under Rennie, and then did the same thing under Lowry (after the requisite setbacks in year 3 and 4 under Rennie…). 

Then wouldn't you know it, toward the end of August, as it started becoming clear that reality was deviating from expectations, I wrote an article about expectations, spelling out why it might be unreasonable for Indy to be burdened with the constant expectation that they be towards the top of the table. History has consistently shown that being at the top of the table is the exception not the norm for the team. Indy is more frequently a middle to bottom resident on the table, with only sporadic forays at the top, and even more infrequent and consistent participants in the league's postseason. 

This year proved to be no different. A Top 4 finish in league play and a run to a semifinal game in the U.S. Open Cup last year with a bulk of the key components of the roster returning this year gave rise to the expectation that Indy should once again be challenging for a league championship this year. As I indicated in my Expectation vs Reality article from when it was said to me, "Conflict arises when expectations exceed reality." 

As the injury bug began to rear its head, the club made no signings to help take the burden off the healthy players until September 3rd, when the team had no choice but to pick up a few loaned players from MLS NextPro teams. The club's expectations of being a top club had been met with "just making due" and budget issues until it could no longer do anything but try and find a few players to round out game day rosters. When the new players were immediately thrown into the starting lineup, it was made visible that Coach McAuley hadn't had enough players to help make game-to-game and in-game adjustments. Yet the loanees weren't enough to settle things and the team finished the final third of the season consistently inconsistent with a 4W-0D-6L record in the final 10 games, including a loss in the final game of the season against Orange County after the door had been opened for them to sneak into the playoffs with a win. Instead, Indy's defeat allowed Detroit to take the final spot in the Eastern Conference, who then took that opening and defeated Louisville in Louisville to bounce the Players' Shield winners in their earliest exit in the history of that club. Proving just how important it is to get into the playoffs in this league. In a one-off game, almost anything can happen.

Speaking about how anything can happen in a one-off game, that was how Indy found themselves out of the Jagermeister Cup as Indy lost to League One side Greenville Triumph after conceding a late goal in the 90th minute. After Greenville forced the Penalty Shootout, Sulte went the wrong way on every Greenville kick and Bryneus missed the team's 6th attempt, and Greenville moved on while Indy's season struggles continued. To that point, Indy had never trailed in the tournament and technically finished the tournament without an official loss, since the Greenville game is officially listed as a draw.

The theme of the 2025 season was missed opportunities. As I indicated in the Orange County recap, not counting the two games in the Jagermeister Cup where Indy conceded late goals that forced the team into penalty kicks, Indy lost 18 points from winning positions, most notably four games when Indy dropped points with just minutes (seconds?) remaining in the game:

  • April 5 draw North Carolina (90'+3') - 2 points lost
  • May 10 draw vs Sacramento (90'+6') - 2 points lost
  • June 21 loss vs Las Vegas (90') - 3 points lost
  • Aug 16 loss vs Loudoun (86') - 3 points lost
Indy also made life difficult for themselves in the Jagermeister Cup when they conceded late, the second of which meant that they were eliminated from the competition at home by a League One team.
  • June 28 "draw" vs Birmingham (90'+4') - win in PK Jagermeister
  • Aug 20 "draw" vs Greenville (90') - loss in PK Jagermeister

Indy's season could have been a lot different.

Coach McAuley has indicated a few times to me, "In football, if you stay the same, you're probably getting worse. So we need to improve next year and improve again and just keep improving."

2025 feels like a step backward from 2024 in many aspects. What happens this offseason could dictate whether 2026 is an improvement year or another backsliding year.

To that end, here are my thoughts when looking towards next season.

Looking to 2026

Stadium

Whatever I said last year about the stadium applies this year. What I said last year was that the stadium was in limbo, and fans didn't know what's going on. Nothing from that perspective has changed. Seemingly, outside of a couple of people, and I'm guessing even that number could be a stretch, nobody seems to know anything about the status of an Indy Eleven stadium. Or nobody is willing to tell me anything about the status of an Indy Eleven stadium. 

The lack of the stadium has meant the continued delay of a women's team, which lead to the departure of the club's most successful coach, persistent comments that the Carroll Stadium surface continues to be a difficult one to play on, and a more vocal frustration from fans who have been required to sit in "American Soccer's Greatest Dive Bar" that is losing its charm. Once a term of affection from fans, the idiosyncrasies of the stadium are starting to wear on fans.  

I have thoughts on the stadium. Coming soon.

Coach
A second season under Coach McAuley was still one of the more successful for an Indy Eleven coach, but reality didn't meet expectations. I don't think it matters. I fully expect McAuley to be back next year, trying to overcome the limitations that are set on Indy Eleven coaches with players. I don't think McAuley did enough to warrant being fired, I would guess a less-than-stellar second head coaching season doesn't have a lot of other teams trying to poach him, and I think he wants to be here. I hope he's back. I've enjoyed my experiences with him. 

I do think he will want to fix an issue that persisted into his second season. Last year, the 59 goals that the team scored were a club record setting total, but unfortunately, they conceded 56 goals. This year, the totals were nearly identical, with the team scoring 55 goals, but they conceded 56 across all competitions. In league play, the team was a -8 in goal differential. Coach is going to want to fix that, which I think he'll have the chance to do when he stays in Indy next season.

Players

I've had relatively decent success guessing which players will be returning in recent years, but when the players that I think could and should return struggled to ninth place in the table, this is one of those years where I could be completely wrong. I think Coach McAuley intends to bring back a core group of this year's team and then bring in new, younger and hungrier, players. Younger players looking to make a name for themselves or older players desperate to show they still have what it takes. McAuley's said some version of that to me and he's also said it on Soccer Saturday. The unknown for me is who he considers to be the most necessary of the "core."

The following is based entirely on my own opinions, but here are the players from this year's roster that I can envision being somewhere else or returning next year.

Gone:

  1. Bryneus - Oliver played just 448 minutes all season. Normally players that have that limited amount of time don't make the next year's roster.
  2. McRobb - the bulk of Finn's 519 minutes happened in a five-game stretch a third of the way into the season as he took his turn at trying to fill the left back role made available due to Stanley's season-ending injury. Once McAuley began to tweak the lineup and settled in on Quinn in that left winger role, McRobb's minutes dwindled to almost nothing. I would be surprised if he returns.
  3. Pruter - Late season loan; back to the Columbus Crew 2 mothership.
  4. Schaefer - Late season loan; back to Cincinnati 2
  5. Zalinsky - Late season loan; back to St. Louis CITY 2

Possibly Gone:

  1. Collier - The leader in the team's substitute appearances (by a wide margin) averaged just over 16 minutes per game in league play and didn't manage to score a goal all season. This was likely year two of a two-year contract and the limited minutes and lack of goals makes it difficult to imagine he returns for another year. At 30 years old, he may be looking for a team where he can find more minutes in what remains of a player's short career.
  2. Hogan - Pat averaged 65 minutes in league play and played in 19 games with 12 starts, but nearly all of those were early in the season. Hogan didn't make an appearance in the final 10 games of the season.
  3. Neidlinger - I guessed correctly that he would be part of the 2025 roster. However, the promise that he showed last year didn't translate to minutes this year, getting just 133 minutes in league play in 7 appearances off the bench. For a kid who accepted a contract to play professional soccer and gave up his college eligibility, he's going to want more minutes. Don't be surprised if you see his name on a League One roster next year trying to get those minutes.
  4. O'Brien, Josh - Was a versatile player that had a reasonable amount of minutes and games played. He wasn't a very expensive contract, so depending on how much that gets negotiated, my gut still tells me that O'Brien won't be around for 2026.
  5. Soumaoro - The arrival of Soumaoro last year pushed Lindley from the starting lineup. Soumaoro's injury this year, and the subsequent reshuffling of the lineup by McAuley, pushed Quinn into a winger role giving him more time to do what he does best which also allowed Lindley back onto the field showing his value. I can see Brem slide into the Returning camp, but for now, I think he doesn't return next year because I think Lindley does return and Lindley demonstrated his value.
  6. Sulte - This will, once again, depend highly on what Portland does with their goalkeeper situation. If they keep all the other guys, they might loan Sulte back to Indy yet again. If they saw enough out of him during his second year here, he might make his way to the Portland first team roster and he will have finished his time here in 2nd place in the team's shutout and saves lists behind Jon Busch.
  7. White - I know McAuley valued White in 2024, but his use this year was sporadic, even without taking into account his injury. He's another player that I could see slide into the Returning list, but for now I'm placing him in the Possibly Gone list.

Probably Returning:

  1. Blake - Unless other teams come calling with more money, which could be possible and likely, Blake is a "core" player to build around. 
  2. Charles-Cook - An outlier to the minimal minutes rule, I think Reice returns next season. He came here with a specific role in mind, that of a backup, but experienced, goalkeeper and he served that role well. He played reasonably well when called upon, including his 10 save game against the Philadelphia Union in the U.S. Open Cup, and he seemed to like his time here in Indiana. I think McAuley and the team keep him around.
  3. Lindley - All of what I said the past two year's applies: "A local guy who was a cornerstone of the roster this year. Cam wants to be in Indy closer to family. There aren't guarantees in the business of soccer, but Lindley returning next season might be close." In an episode of the Indy Eleven Coaches Show, McAuley said, "Two quick things I said to the players at the start of the season. Performance and attitude will keep you at the club. If one of them is not there, the one I'm choosing is attitude. If your performance is not there, but you've got a good attitude, you've got a good chance of staying. If your performance is there, and your attitude is not there, you're not staying. And if you've got both, then we've got a decent squad. Simple enough?" From my perspective, Lindley's attitude and talent are both there. I don't see how the team doesn't keep him around.
  4. Murphy - This season, the starting lineup became very predictable as injuries and performances dictated who would be on the field. For two years, you could basically put Murphy's name on the starting lineup in Sharpie. He finished the season having played in all 30 league games, all 5 Jagermeister Cup games, and 1 of 2 of the U.S. Open Cup games. His minutes did drop off a little at the end of the year, so I have to wonder if his fitness began to take a hit as the season drew to a close due to the minutes and miles he has put in over the past two years. Regardless, he'll be back. 
  5. Musa - Began to find a starter role in the tail end of the 2024 season and grabbed it with both hands in 2025. He played in one less game than Murphy, but played more minutes. The defense had a habit of leaking bad goals, but I still think he returns.
  6. Ofeimu - Indy conceded a lot of goals and at inopportune times, but I don't know how many I would consider to have been Ofeimu's fault. Just a guess, but I think he returns next season..
  7. Quinn - In the past two Soccer Saturday's with Rakestraw, Quinn was mentioned by McAuley or interviewed outright. In both instances it was said, while not "official" yet, Quinn will be back next year. It could be his last year here depending on how well his body holds up, but it might not be his last in Indy if there's a way to keep him around as he transitions to a coaching role.
  8. Rendon - The jump from League One to the Championship wasn't seamless and he had some moments where you could tell he was still adjusting. His pace and his ability to defend and go forward, make him a player that I think McAuley keeps around.
  9. Stanley - Other than Murphy, until his season-ending injury, Stanley was another you could put into the staring lineup with a Sharpie. Despite no data on which to evaluate him after the 8th game, I think Stanley will return.
I hear you. Where are the forwards? What do I think is going to happen with Amoh, Foster, Kizza, and Williams? I don't know which ones will be staying or leaving, but I would bet that only one or two of them return. I can make arguments for each of them, but I'm really not sure which one(s) McAuley values more than the others. My gut says it might be Foster and Williams even though Amoh was the second leading scorer in all competitions behind Blake. Foster's speed and desire to take on defenders sets him apart. Williams' hold-up play sets him apart. Who stays and who goes may have a lot to do with what players the team recruits to come to Indy.
  1. Amoh
  2. Foster
  3. Kizza
  4. Williams