Showing posts with label Hogsett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hogsett. Show all posts

Monday, September 28, 2026

Indy Eleven to League One?

A couple weeks ago, Athletic Club Boise was announced as making the jump from USL League One up to the Championship for the 2027 season. With the announcement, Kartik Krishnaiyer from Beyond the 90', asked a very simple question, with a less than simple answer. "Why is a team paying an expansion fee to jump divisions when an open sporting ladder is supposedly right around the corner?"

Looking around the world, at teams that hover in the middle of their division for extended periods, I have to wonder if that plays into their thinking and Kartik's article suggests as much. Going down divisions can be simple. Getting back up can be much more of a challenge. By putting themselves into the Championship early, they get to see the level of competition before the promotion/relegation arrangement gets started. So when pro/rel makes its way to the USL pyramid, they're ready to compete, at a minimum, at the Championship level and not have to work their way up from League One. It does have other ramifications which Kartik discusses in detail, but where you start in the pyramid can go a long way to where you stay in the pyramid depending on how you spend.

Which gets me to the actual point of this article, which you've likely already guessed was going to be more Indy Eleven-centric based on the title. 

Indy Eleven have been a USL Championship team since 2018. For nine seasons, the Indy Eleven have been considered by many to be one of the premier organizations in the league, despite its less than consistent results and playoff appearances. Of the eight previous seasons in the league, Indy has made the playoffs half of the time, but have been bounced from the playoffs in the first round in three of the four seasons (2018 - Louisville 4-1; 2023 - Charleston 5-0; 2024 - Rhode Island 2-3), with the lone exception being the 2019 season where the team made the Eastern Conference Final. Indy's ability to make this year's playoffs could push them just above or just below .500 in their ability to play games beyond the league season.

And yet, this year's team feels like it's not fully prepared to be in the USL-C, despite its tenure and its current spot in the table. They currently sit in 7th place in the Eastern Conference, but with a roster and some results that give off League One vibes. In fact, this season, thanks to the U.S. Open Cup and the Prinx Tires USL Cup, Indy have played a League One team four times this year; Union Omaha twice, Fort Wayne, and Forward Madison. In those games, Indy lost to Union Omaha twice, drew Fort Wayne after conceding in 2nd half stoppage time, and beat Forward Madison for a 1W-1D-2L record. All three teams are currently in a playoff position, so maybe Indy is a fringe USL-C playoff team, but a solid League One playoff team? Indy's struggles this past weekend with Miami as some key components of the "first team" level players have continued to be beaten by the injury bug highlighted Indy's lack of elite depth at all positions.

As I've stated a few times this year, I've been told that Indy has the lowest salary in the league. "Per club policy, terms of the deal will not be disclosed" is Indy's standard language when it comes to player contracts, but the rumor is that Indy's total team salary is $1.2M (whereas I've heard that Loudoun is at $1.8M and Tampa is at $2.2M). There are a couple of things that interest me about that value:

  1. I have to assume that the midfield veteran triumvirate of Blake, Lindley, and Quinn, and Dick might all be making at least $100k each based on their league value (transfermarkt has them all higher than that number). Which means that the rest of the team is working at the league minimum. Rendon's transfermarkt value is also high, so I'm not sure how that's possible without the entirety of the rest of the team working second jobs (or housing benefits on top of the salary?), so the vets might be making less than my assumption.
  2. That value rings a bell for me, because Peter Wilt conveyed to me that Indy's inaugural season in 2014 was (drumroll...) $1.2M. I'm positive that the amount has increased in the 13 seasons, but if the rumors are correct, the number has again dropped back down to inaugural season levels. Based only on inflation numbers, Indy's $1.2M salary in 2014 would need to be at $1.8M today to get the same spending value. Yet we all know that USL-C now is a much better, and more expensive, league than NASL then, so Indy's current 7th place in the table is really kind of impressive. Currently punching above their weight based on salary, but Indy should probably be spending closer to $2M to have an overall roster that can legitimately compete with the top teams in the League. Easy to say when it's not my money. 

So the question that comes to my mind is "why"? Why is Indy spending so much less now than they were likely spending just a few seasons ago? Why hasn't there been any kind of stadium update from the team in over two years? Why did Indy lose very good parts of their front office staff last year en masse? 

Why does it feel like Indy is operating at a League One level?

It doesn't seem like Ersal's personality to willingly drop down a level to League One, but he's also not seemingly making many outward steps to stay within USL-C or prepare for a potential step up to the future USL Premier, which will require Division 1 standards. Detroit and Pittsburgh have plans in place to get their stadiums to Premier level, Louisville City's stadium already meets the capacity requirement, and North Carolina is on hiatus this year to prep for Premier. So teams are already preparing for the Premier league launch two years from now in 2028. However, Indy's Eleven Park seems fitting that it was intended to be located on a former cemetery because all outward indications are that the project is dead, with no announced plans in two years. After the groundbreaking in 2023, the demolition of the Diamond Chain buildings took place, but everything ground to a halt in 2024. Carroll Stadium, as currently arranged, can seat 10,000 to 12,000 depending on the utilization of the grandstands and the layout of "temporary" stands. Carroll could probably be further expanded with temporary stands to get to 15,000 (the Division 1 requirement), but that would continue to feel like lipstick on a pig. 

So if Ersal and Indy Eleven seemingly aren't preparing for USL Premier, and have continued to decrease salaries within USL-C to the point where Coach McAuley and the current roster are overachieving based on their respective league-wide salary, is Ersal planning to be in League One without making the mirror action of Boise? The team hasn't actively announced a plan to go to League One, but is that the plan? Obviously, nobody in the club has said anything even close to this to me. This is just a "what if?" exercise for me. An exercise that I can't immediately decide isn't a possibility.

The recent round of MLS to Indy discussion actually helps Ersal in this regard. It gives him an excuse if/when the club drops levels or, potentially, fails altogether and shutters. Ersal can claim (maybe rightfully) that Mayor Hogsett's 2024 actions made it difficult to attract the highest level players and, just as importantly, significant level sponsors when nobody knows if the team will be around. While some cities can support multiple professional soccer teams, it's doubtful that Indianapolis is one of them. So Ersal has an "out" when he decides to stop losing money on this venture and closes shop. "The Mayor began the downward spiral" might not be 100% accurate, but there is a definite point in the history of Indy Eleven, from April 2024 when the mayor announced his plans to pull the funding of Eleven Park from Ersal and work towards an MLS team, that things haven't seemed "right" with the club. 

"Conflict arises when expectations exceed reality." When I wrote that last August, my closing statement of the article was:

The expectation is that Indy will be competing for Championships in a world class facility. The reality is that Indy has been a club with middling results and above average announced attendance, but is struggling to come to grips with the fact that all outward signs point to Indy playing forever in Carroll Stadium or failing and ceasing to be.

In the subsequent 13 months, I have now begun to wonder if there isn't another caveat on the table, which is a drop in leagues to League One. This would allow Ersal to continue to have a professional soccer team on his resume, but at a much lower financial burden. A financial burden he's probably closer to spending anyway based on this year's salary. Every so often though, the team could overperform and get promoted back up to the Championship, but in either case, Carroll Stadium is still an "acceptable" stadium. 

Unless, of course, my other idea for financial stability that includes moving the team to Grand Park comes to fruition. Though, actually both ideas could come into play since the Grand Park Master Plan includes a 10,000 seat stadium, which would work for either a Championship or League One level team.

I know many fans hated my idea of a Grand Park-based Indy Eleven, but what would be your thoughts of a League One-based Indy? Are the remaining fans really "XI 'til I die" no matter the league or level, or would that be the final straw? Would an Indy Eleven team that bounced between the Championship and League One because that's the salary level that Ersal was willing to spend be acceptable?

My guess is that Ersal has always had First Division aspirations, but at some point, time and money and a rug-pulling mayor may have become too much for him to handle. Time may tell us whether a League One Indy Eleven is the goal or just the result.

Wednesday, May 29, 2024

Eleven Park AKA Titanic Park

 Let me start with some prefaces.

  1. I did not attend the City-County Council meeting on Tuesday May 28th, 2024. Nearly everything I gleaned from that meeting was obtained via X, and specifically, Kurt Darling of WIBC. I will reference his name throughout, but not all the links. Go to his X page and you'll find them all there. Thanks Kurt!
  2. My first article about an Indy Eleven stadium happened in December 2014 where I discussed the site near the Heliport. Does that make me an expert? No. Does it mean that I have spent a long time thinking about an Indy Eleven stadium? Yes. The location is not something new, even though it might feel that way right now.
  3. I don't know anything more than what most people know. The people that wouldn't talk to me before still won't talk to me. The people that I used to think would give me an honest opinion, I don't think will do that anymore. Certainly not on-record. Is that going to stop me from giving my thoughts now? Hell no.
Let's move onto the basics from tonight's meeting. The CCC approved the proposal to create a second Professional Sports Development Area (PSDA2) by a vote of 6 yea, 4 nay, 1 abstain. Per Mr. Darling:

Annee: No
Bain: Yes
Boots: Yes
Brown: Yes
Dilk: No
Lewis: No
Mowery: No
Neilsen: Yes
Perkins: Yes
Robinson: Abstain
Osili: Yes

Mr. Darling conveyed this little nugget that I will discuss more later: 
Councilor Evans asks Deputy Mayor Parker what's next if the MLS proposal is defeated.
"If PSDA2 is defeated, we will not be building a soccer stadium. Period," he said.

Many eggs versus two big eggs:
City attorney Scott Chinn explains that the new proposal has "more eggs in one basket" as opposed to only "two big eggs" with Eleven Park.  

He says the new proposal is a lot more diverse as a tax district and keeps city liability to fill in the "gap" at a minimum.

And finally:
Deputy Mayor Dan Parker says the city backed out of the Eleven Park proposal because it "presented too much risk to city taxpayers." He says the new MLS proposal has "much less risk."

He added the "gap" in fiscal liability the city would take on with Eleven Park was "too big."

Now let's move to my thoughts.

I absolutely agree with Deputy Mayor Parker that "we" (the City of Indianapolis) will not be building a soccer stadium. The passing of the proposal in all reality kills the Eleven Park stadium at the PSDA1 site. With the deadline for the financial portion of the PSDA law fast approaching, the City and the Mayor will now move forward at full speed trying to get the PSDA2 area finalized and Keystone/Ersal don't have enough time to come up with a PSDA3 site. What I suspect happens is that 1) the Mayor's Office somehow manages to get part of the way there but don't succeed in jumping through all the legal hoops, thereby killing the PSDA2 stadium, or 2) they do manage to make it through the hoops and MLS says, "nay, that's okay, thanks for playing our game though," thereby killing the PSDA2 stadium. Since the Mayor already killed PSDA1, Indy doesn't build a soccer stadium. Deputy Mayor Parker tells the truth. The MLS proposal has "much less risk" on "City taxpayers" because nothing gets built. No real risk when there isn't anything built.

As I discussed in my last article about the resolution, the Mayor's Office's plan definitely spreads around the PSDA2 throughout the 1-mile radius allowed by the law. That's the "many eggs" versus Keystone/Ersal's Eleven Park development "big eggs." Looking at all the locations that the Mayor's office included in the PSDA2, I question whether even the combined effort of all those locations would be enough to "fill in the gap" if the stadium doesn't make the money expected. However, I've read through earlier financial proposals for the stadiums, and nearly all of them are more optimistic about revenue than I would think prudent and that hasn't changed from the time the PSDA1 was discussed. It isn't like the Mayor didn't see those projections months/years ago. Moving the "other revenue" sources to dozens of sites from just the one Eleven Park site doesn't change the financials that much based on what I saw. 

If there were any grown-ups in the room, here's how I can see this thing moving forward that actually benefits everybody. 

Oh wait. One other thing that was mentioned in the meeting and that continues to be a sticking point for me is that the Mayor's Office has yet to publicly state who is included in this mysterious MLS investor's group. If you're using public funds for the stadium portion, contingent upon the success of those investor's ability to get into MLS, I think the public should have access to those persons, even if the soccer team to MLS is a private to private exchange. 

Okay, back to what I was saying. Grown-ups in the room. Nearly all of this is stuff that I have been saying for weeks, none of it publicly until I could get more information. Since that seems like that is going to be impossible to obtain, I'm just going to say it now out loud as my unsolicited thoughts.

The main points are as follows:

  1. PSDA1 and PSDA2 should merge. 
  2. The City should pay the cost to inter however many remains are found.
  3. MLS to Indy Eleven
  4. Punch your weight.

1. The concept of spreading around the tax base in the PSDA is a good idea. Having a stadium and a core development around it is also a good idea. I'm not sure that the original concept of the PSDA and the law was written around included using existing businesses, but rather was written more with the intent of providing new businesses and "transformational developments" to grow the City. However, best I can tell, it doesn't preclude the use of the existing businesses either. If the Mayor's Office didn't think that the rest of the Eleven Park development was going to be enough in a stadium shortfall, why not maintain that development and just add to it? The Mayor's idea isn't necessarily a poor one, just a poorly executed one at the moment. The stadium with the Eleven Park developments PLUS the other businesses should provide enough financial backstop. Why does it have to be either/or? Nearly everything associated with the stadium/MLS right now is hearsay, rumors, or lies. If nobody else has to say their sources, then my comments aren't any different, but I heard that the Mayor can't get his PSDA2 site. So he's on the verge of having a PSDA without a stadium site, which means no stadium, which means no MLS, which, ultimately, means this all has occurred for nothing, Unless you believe the conspiracy theorists out there that MLS is actively trying to kill off the "marquee" names in USL, in which case everything else in this article doesn't matter if that's true and Garber wins. Back to the point of this bullet item though, a combined PSDA1 + PSDA2 makes sense...in conjunction with below item #2. 

2. The very first time that the City allowed a development to occur on the Greenlawn Cemetery site without first having moved every single remain from it, the City made a mistake. The City then compounded that mistake over and over again. While some of those remains were likely considered "property" at that time, that's a mistake we can fix now. A mistake that no single developer (however hastily they purchased the property without fully vetting the site) should have to bear alone. The mistakes were our ancestors' and the bill has come due. Without properly interring the remains, the site will remain undevelopable and if that's the case, we might as well let Keystone sell the land back to the City, throw down some sod or seed, and put a sign by the road renaming the land Greenlawn Cemetery. Whether there is 1 remain, 650 remains, or the 15,000 remains that was mentioned in the meeting, the site is still a cemetery until the remains have been removed. That's on all of us. 

3. If MLS comes to Indianapolis, they should come to Indy Eleven. I, personally, don't care if that's with Ersal Ozdemir or some unknown investors with Ersal as a minority owner because he sells his team's name to the MLS owners for their use. There is no MLS talk in 2024 without Indy Eleven. That's a fact and one that shouldn't be overlooked by anybody on the MLS side of things. 

4. It's also okay to just punch your weight. John Cusack in High Fidelity provided me with that line that I'm going to adjust here for my use. "The thing I learned from the whole [MLS] debacle was that you have to punch your own weight. You see, [MLS], she's out of my class. ... Too much. I mean, what am I? I'm a middleweight. Hey, I'm not the smartest guy in the world, but I'm certainly not the dumbest." Naptown, that's us. It's okay to be a middleweight. It's okay to be the best damn middleweight that you can be. That could mean the team stops thinking about MLS and just tries to be the best damn USL Championship (or USL Premier if the often discussed pro/rel version of USL ever happens) they can be. In the words of Stephen Stills, "And if you can't be with the one you love, honey love the one you're with." Utilize the new billionaire owner Chuck Surack to help privately fund a 15k seat stadium that can be expanded if that need arrives, sooner or later. Punch your weight.

Since I'm not seeing any grown-ups, here's what I think could (or does) actually happen:

  1. PSDA2 kills PSDA1.
  2. MLS kills PSDA2.
  3. Indy Eleven still without a stadium (more than a dozen years into its founding while new USL Championship side Rhode Island FC is already in the process of building a stadium) seeks other options that don't include a PSDA with an Indianapolis politician.
    1. See above discussion about punching your weight.
    2. Ersal/Keystone convince Mayor of Westfield that a stadium located in/around Grand Park makes for a good idea and synergy, hoping a different politician will be better.
      Narrator: "It won't."
  4. As best I can tell, while Indy Eleven can technically use Carroll Stadium for its women's USL Super League team (reminder, that's a Division 1 level league, on par with NWSL), the lack of their own stadium kills the women's professional team because fans don't want to sit at Carroll Stadium in the winter and the players don't want to play on the turf in the winter. Players like Katie Soderstrom, who came back to Indy from a pro career in Europe, I think partially intrigued by the idea of being part of Indy Eleven's inaugural Super League team, watch that dream remain just a dream.
I've said it before on this site. This club isn't perfect. It's owner(s) isn't perfect. 

Right now, though, me writing this article is starting to feel like I'm part of the band playing on the Titanic. Titanic Park.