To date, Indy Eleven have played in leagues that are considered to be the Second Division of the United States soccer pyramid; initially in the NASL and then (and now) in the USL Championship. As a result, most players tend to have short-term tenures in Indianapolis. However, Indy fans have always considered that once a player is part of the Indy Eleven family, they will remain #IndyForever. While it is often difficult to keep tabs of players once they have retired from the game of soccer, this page will attempt to be a repository of players who have moved onto other teams, but are still playing professionally or have joined the coaching ranks. The page will not always be accurate as it won't be constantly updated, but I will do my best to periodically evaluate and keep track of players and their new clubs.
National Women's Soccer League
- Hal Hershfelt - Washington Spirit and U.S. National Team
- Mackenzie Wood - Chicago Red Stars
USL Super League
- Annika Creel - Carolina Ascent
- Emma Johnson - Lexington SC
- Rachel McCarthy - Dallas Trinity FC
- Trinity Watson - Lexington SC
Other Women Leagues
- Robyn McCarthy - IK Grand Bodø (Norwegian First Division)
- Molly McLaughlin - SK Slavia Praha (Czech First Division)
Major League Soccer (& MLSNEXTPRO)
- Conner Antley - DC United
- Josh Penn - Portland Timbers 2 (MLS Next Pro)
- Jordan Farr - DC United
- Elliot Panicco - Nashville SC
- Jeremy Rafanello - Philadelphia Union
- Kleberson - New York City FC (Assistant Coach)
- Juan Guerra - Houston Dynamo (Assistant Coach)
- Liam Doyle - Huntsville City FC (Director of Soccer Operations)
- Nicky Law - North Texas SC (Assistant Coach)
USL Championship
- Manuel Arteaga - Tampa Bay Rowdies
- Danny Barbir - Lexington SC
- Younes Boudadi - Las Vegas Lights
- Rece Buckmaster - San Antonio FC
- Alex Crognale - San Antonio FC
- Robbie Dambrot - Loudoun United
- Eric Dick - Pittsburgh Riverhounds
- Adrian Diz Pe - Hartford
- Jonas Fjeldberg - Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC
- Neveal Hackshaw - Oakland Roots SC
- Tyler Gibson - Oakland Roots
- Sebastian Guenzatti - Detroit City FC
- Justin Ingram - Hartford Athletic
- Cal Jennings - Charleston Battery
- Duke Lacroix - Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC
- Douglas Martinez - Charleston Battery
- Ben Mines - Loudoun United
- Nick Moon - Tampa Bay Rowdies
- Kevin Partida - Orange County SC
- Tyler Pasher - Birmingham Legion FC
- Patrick Seagrist - FC Tulsa
- Juan Tejada - Colorado Springs Switchbacks FC
- Jared Timmer - Sacramento Republic FC
- Augustine Williams - Pittsburgh Riverhounds
- Jon Busch - Pittsburgh Riverhounds (Goalkeeper Coach)
- Matt Watson - FC Tulsa (Assistant Coach)
- Trevor James - Detroit City FC (Sporting Director)
USL League One
- Solomon Asante - Texoma FC
- Karsen Henderlong - FC Naples
- Mechack Jerome - Union Omaha
- Sean Lewis - One Knoxville SC
- Mitch Osmond - Forward Madison FC
- Noah Powder - Westchester SC
- Max Schneider - Union Omaha
- Sebastian Velasquez - Greenville Triumph SC
- Laurence Wooton - Union Omaha
- Eamon Zayed - Northern Colorado Hailstorm FC (Head Coach)
- Colin Falvey - Northern Colorado Hailstorm FC (Assistant Coach)
USL League Two
- Kenney Walker - King's Hammer FC
- Amass Amankona - South Bend Lions
National Independent Soccer Association
- Alioune Diakhate - Salt City Union
Other Leagues
- Paddy Barrett - Shelbourne (Ireland Premier Division)
- Yeferson Contreras - HNK Sibenik (Croatia)
- Reiner Ferreira - Boa Esporte Clube (Campeonato Brasileiro Série C)
- Jordan Hamilton - Shan United (Myanmar National League)
- Gershon Koffie - Sandecja Nowy Sącz (Poland)
- Aidan Liu - B68 Toftir ( Faroese)
- Nico Matern - FC Teutonia Ottensen (Germany)
- Rodney Michael - FK Mornar Bar (Montenegro)
- Corby Moore - Dorchester Town FC (Southern League Premier Division South - England)
- Cristian Novoa - Carabobo FC (Venezuelan Primera División)
- Jair Reinoso - Club Strongest (Bolivia)
- Gabriel Rodrigues - Figueirense FC (Campeonato Brasileiro Série B)
- Aboubacar Sissoko - Forge FC (Canada)
- Cammy Smith - Peterhead (Scottish League One)
- Dragan Stojkov - FK Rabotnički (Macedonian First League)
- Soony Saad - Michigan Wolves SC (Assistant Coach)
- Owain Fon Williams - Bolton Wanderers (Goalkeeper Coach)
- Jeremiah Gutjahr - IU Men's Soccer (Director of Operations)
- Christian Lomeli - IU Men's Soccer (Assistant coach)
- Tanner Thompson - IU Men's Soccer (Assistant coach)
- Sinisa Ubiparipovic (Coach - Cleveland State University)
