- 2014 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2015 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2016 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2016 Indy Eleven NPSL Roster
- 2017 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2018 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2019 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2020 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2021 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2022 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2022 Indy Eleven USL-W Roster
- 2023 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2023 Indy Eleven USL-W Roster
- 2024 Indy Eleven Roster
- 2024 Indy Eleven USL-W Roster
#IndyForever - List of players who have moved on from Indy with their new clubs
NOTE: 4 roster signings are not included in the detailed roster listings above.
- Stephen DeRoux - Signed, but did not pass team physical and was released.
- Dino Williams - Signed, but did not pass team physical and was released.
- Braden Tamosaitis - Signed a one-day contract with the team.
- Cal Jennings - Jennings was signed in December 2020, but was transferred to Los Angeles Football Club (LAFC) of MLS in March 2021. Cal left Indy having never suited up for the team, including preseason games.